Bhuidhar and Another v. State of U.P. and 6 Others

Court No. - 51 Case :- WRIT - C No. - 34047 of 2023 Petitioner :- Bhuidhar And Another Respondent :- State Of U.P. And 6 Others Counsel for Petitioner :- Hira Lal Counsel for Respondent :- C.S.C.,Ajay Kumar Srivastava,Anup Kumar Srivastava,Bhupendra Kumar Tripathi,Shashi Ranjan Srivastava Hon'ble Chandra Kumar Rai,J.

¶1Heard Mr. Ayub Khan, Advocate assisted by Mr. Hira Lal, learned counsel for the petitioners, Mr. Anil Srivastava, learned Standing Counsel for the State-respondents, Mr. Anup Kumar Srivastava, learned counsel for respondent nos.6 & 7 and Mr. Bhupendra Kumar Tripathi, learned counsel for the respondent-Land Management Committee.

¶2Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the mutation application filed on behalf of private respondents on the basis of alleged Will-deed, has been allowed in arbitrary manner. He further submitted that the petitioner is claiming right on the basis of succession but without considering the case of the petitioners, the order for mutation on the basis of alleged Will-deed has been passed on 7.10.2022 by the Tahsildar. He next submitted that the appeal and revision filed by the petitioners have been also dismissed without considering the case of the petitioners. He also submitted that the petitioners have filed suit No.926 of 2013 for cancellation of the alleged Will-deed, which is pending before the Civil Court, as such, the impugned order passed by the Tahsildar as maintained in appeal and revision be set aside and matter be examined afresh in accordance with law.

¶3On the other hand, Mr. Anup Kumar Srivastava, learned counsel for the private respondent nos.6 & 7, Mr. Bhupendra Kumar Tripathi, learned counsel for the Land Management Committee and Mr. Anil Srivastava learned Standing Counsel for State submitted that the mutation application has been allowed on the basis of registered Will-deed, as such, unless the Will-deed is cancelled in accordance with law, the mutation application filed by the private respondents cannot be dismissed. They further submitted that the mutation application has been rightly allowed and the order has been rightly maintained in appeal and revision. They next submitted that the civil suit for cancellation of the Will-deed filed on behalf of the petitioners is pending before the civil Court, as such, no interference is required and the revision is liable to be dismissed.

¶4I have considered the argument advanced by learned counsel for the parties and perused the records.

¶5There is no dispute about the fact that the Tahsildar has passed the order of mutation on the basis of Will-deed in favour of private respondents on 7.10.2020. There is also no dispute about the fact that the order dated 7.10.2020 has been maintained in appeal vide order dated 10.1.2022. There is also no dispute about the fact that revisional Court has dismissed the petitioners' revision on 17.4.2022. There is also no dispute about the fact that the Civil Suit No.926 of 2013 filed by the petitioners for cancellation of the Will-deed executed in favour of the private respondents is pending before the Civil Judge, Junior Division, Hawali, Varanasi.

¶6In order to appreciate the controversy involved in the matter, perusal of order dated 7.10.2020 passed by the Tahsildar will be relevant, which is as follows: "

आददशपतक

नययययलययतहससलदयर, नययययक

मणडलयवयरयणसस,

जनपदयवयरयणसस,

तहससलयरयजयतयलयब

वयदससखययय-758/2014

कसपययटरसककतवयदससखययय-T2014147003758

ददरयरवतसददवसबनयमसनतरयम

असतररतधयरयय-34/35, अधधयनयमय-उ०प०भय-

रयजसवअधधयनयम,1901 यनणरय

उभयपककदयवदयनअधधवकयरणककममधखकबहससदनसरयसतथयआपधतकतयरणकदयवदयनअधधवकयदयरय

पसतदतधलधखतबहसककददखयरययतथययवदयनअधधवकयरणदयरयपसतदतयवधधवयवसथयओसकदआलककममपतयवलस

कयअवलककनयकययरयय।पसतदतवससयतनयमयककधलधखतखयतदयरदयरयतहरसरकरपसजसककतकरयययरययहह।

धजसकददकननरवयहभरवनतयवयवजयकदमयरपटदलदयरयनययययलयममउपससथतहककरअपनद-

अपनदबययनवधजरहकद

मयधयमसदवससयतनयमयककसययबतकरतदहहयदकहयरययहहयकपतयवलसपरउपलबधयहवहसवससयतहहधजसपर

ससतयरयमनदहसतयकरएवसयनशयनसअरयठयलरयययहहधजसपरमदरदहसतयकरहह।वससयतहमयरदसमकउपयनबसधकरसरयपदर

यनबसधधतहह।इसपकयरवससयतनयमयककरवयहनदयरयसययबतयकययरययहह।आपधतकतयरणदयरयआपधतककउनकक

इचछयकदयवपरसतउनककनयजयनकयरसममतहरसरकरयययजयनयकहयरययहह।यहभसकहयरययहहयकवससयतकतयरकक

वकदयपनकदकयरणसकचनदसमझनदककशयकसमयपहकचदककथस।इसधलएवससयतनयमयससयदगधवफजरहह।इससमबसध

ममआपधतकतयरणदयरयरवयहनकदबययनवधजरहअसयकतकरययदरयदहहयकवससयतकतयरआपधतकतयरववससयतगयहतय

कदससयदकपररवयरकदसयथरहकरसदवयपयतदथद।आपधतकतयरकदयवदयनअधधवकयदयरयअपनदतकरममकहयरययहहयक

मकतकवससयतकतयरकदवयसतयवकउतरयधधकयररयनकदपकममसहसतरसकदसदवरयसतआददशदजरहकचदकयहह,

औरसभस

तसननभयईअपनद-

अपनदअसशकदमदतययबककययबजहह।वससयतनयमययबलकदलजयलसवफजरदसतयवदजहह।धजसद

यनषपययदतयकयदजयनदकययवशदषकयरणनहहदशयरययरययहह।वससयतनयमयमयतपयररवयररकसदसयनकदअसशककहडपनद

कदधलएसयधजशकदतहततहरसरकरयययरययहह।इससमबसधममयवधधवयवसथय2009 आर.डस.

पदज250 व2015 आर.डस.

पदज323,2007 आर.डस.

पदज128

आयदकयहवयलयददतदहहयदतकरपसतदतयकययरययहहयकवससयतनयमय

ककयवधधनदसयरपमययणतनहहकरयययरययहहतथयवससयतनयमयकदआधयरपरपररवयरकदअनयसदसयनकदयहतसद

बसयचतयकययरययहह।पररससथयतययसससददहयसपदहह।जबयकवययदनसकदयवदयनअधधवकयदयरयअपनदतकरममकहयरयय

यकवससयतनयमयपसजसककतदसतयवदजहहधजसदयनयमयनदसयरउसकददकननरवयहनदयरयसययबतयकययरययहह।इससमबसध

ममयवधधवयवसथय2002

रय०यन०सस०पदज370 सद373 व1993

रय०यन०सस०पदज26 सद31 व1991

रय०यन०सस०पदज24

कयहवयलयपसतदतकरतदहहयदयहमतवयकयकययरयययकवससयतनयमयपसजसककतहहजकज०यव०

एवसभय०वय०अधध०ककधयरय169

सदअनदधययतकरतसहहकयनयकवससयतकतयरभयमधरवययकहह।उकतथयनएवस

सयकयनसदसपषहहयकपसतदतवससयतनयमयययदपसजसककतदसतयवदजहहधजसदधलधखतखयतदयरदयरयतहरसरयकययरयय

हह।धजसकददकननरवयहनदयरयनययययलयममउपससथतहककरयवधधनदसयरसययबतयकययरययहह।ऐससससथयतमम

आपधतकतयरणककआपधतकदजकतथयहहवससयतनयमयककफजरवससयदगधकहयरययहह।नयमयसतरणकककययरवयहस

एकसरसरसपयकययहह।धजसकदअनतररतपसजसककतदसतयवदजककबहधययनकतयपरसदनवयईकयकदतयधधकयरइस

नययययलयककपयपनहहहह।वससयतयवधधनदसयरसययबतहह।अतयआपधतयदनयसक24.01.2014

बलहसनहकनदकद

कयरणयनरसतयकययजयतयहह।पसतदतवससयतनयमयकदआधयरपरनयमयसतरणकककययरवयहसयकययजयनयववरयसत

आददशयनरसतयकययजयनयउयचतपतसतहकतयहह।ममजयभतसयरपररनयकसवयररयजयतहससलरयजयतयलयबधजलय

वयरयणससककखतमनसवषर1417-1422

फ०कदखयतयसस०744 व242

परदजरप०क०11

खकयरयजसव

यनरसककरकहयनययसआददशयदनयसक28.06.2013

यनरसतकरतदहहयदवतरमयनखतमनसवषर1423-1428

फ०कदखयतय

सस०160 व252

परदजरवयररसनचनदबलसवमहदनदवभदईधरपदतरणसव०बदचयकयनयमयनरसतकरकदवससयतकतयर

सनतयरयमउफरसनतरयमपदतभगरयउफरमगघयकदसथयनपरजररयदपसजसककतवससयतनयमयददरयरवतसददवसपतनसचनदबलस

पटदलयनवयधसनसममजयभतसयर(लयहयय)

पररनयकसवयररयजयतहससलरयजयतयलयबधजलयवयरयणससकयनयम

ससकमणसयभयमधरसहखयतदयरदजरहक।बयदअमलदरयमदपतयवलसदय०द०हक। … यदनयसक ...

ह०अप० 07/10/20

तहससलदयर(नययययक) रयजयतयलयब वयरयणसस"

¶7Perusal of finding of fact recorded by the Tahsildar reveals that mutation order has been passed on the basis of registered Will-deed. It is also material that civil suit at the instance of the petitioners for cancellation of Will-deed is pending before the civil Court.

¶8Considering the findings of fact recorded by the Tahsildar as well as pendency of civil suit at the instance of the petitioners, no interference is required against the impugned judgments.

¶9The writ petition is dismissed. Needless to say that the order passed in the mutation proceedings shall not come in the way of the petitioners to establish their claim in accordance with law in the pending civil suit. Order Date :- 30.11.2023 Rameez High Court of Judicature at Allahabad