Ex No.134451F. Havildar/Gd Nandu Lal v. Union of India and Anr

Serial No.19-23 Regular List HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA AT SHILLONG WP(C). No. 353 of 2021 with WP(C). No.471 of 2021 WP(C). No. 472 of 2021 WP(C). No. 182 of 2022 WP(C). No. 45 of 2023.

Date of Order : 22.08.2024 WP(C). No. 353 of 2021

¶1Shri. Dibyendu Deb, Hav (GD).

¶2Shri. Nizamuddin Khan, Hav (GD).

¶3Shri. Prasad Acharya, Hav (GD).

¶4Shri. Arbind Kumar Singh, Hav (GD).

¶5Md. Kalimullah, Warrant Officer (GD).

¶6Md. Tausir Ansari, Hav (GD).

¶7Sri Sarwan Kumar, Hav (GD)

¶8Sri Kishor Kumar Chhetri, Rfn (Flr).

¶9Sri. Ram Binay Kumar, Hav (GD)

¶1North Block,

¶2Shillong – 793011.

¶3The Joint Secretary (Police) to the Govt. of India, Ministry of Home Affairs, Coram: Hon'ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Chief Justice (Acting) Mr. M.Chanda, Adv. Mr. M.L.Nongpiur, Adv. Mr. K.Abhinaba, Adv.

: WP(C). No. 471 of 2021

¶1No.G/134460H, Warrant Officer/GD Rakesh Kumar Sharma.

¶2No. 134447Y Naib Subedar/GD Ram Awadh.

¶3No. 134441 Warrant Officer/GD Samuel Kutty N.A.

¶4No. 134446W Havildar/GD Lallan Yadav.

¶5No. 134461L, Warrant Officer/GD Saji B.

¶6No. 134470M, Warrant Officer/GD Ram Probodh Sahoo.

¶7No. 134472X Havildar/GD Bram Dev Yadav.

¶8No. 134474H Warrant Officer/GD Suresh Yadav.

¶9No. 134440 Rifleman/GD Yamuna Singh.

¶10No. 134466 Havildar/GD

Tulsi Singh.

¶11No. 2025L Havildar/GD

K.Mani Mohan Singha.

¶12No. 184597 Rifleman/GD

Veer Bahadur Singh Chauhan.

¶13No. 371086 Havildar/NA

Udayan M.

¶14380349 Naib Subedar Jaya Kumar V.

¶15No. 153436 Havildar/GD

Muhamad Sdaifa S.

¶16No. 153440 Warrant Officer/GD

Pali Ram.

¶17No. 153435 Havildar/GD Nripendra Debnath.

¶18No. 153444 Havildar/GD N.K.Giri.

¶19No. 371217M Havildar/N.A. Kuldeep Singh.

1.

2.

¶3The Commandant, 13th Assam Rifles C/o 99APO, Pin – 932013.

¶4The Commandant, 15th Assam Rifles C/o 99APO, Pin-932015.

: WP(C). No. 472 of 2021

¶1Ex.No. 134475L, Havidar/GD Shali Ram.

¶2Ex. No. 134442 Havildar/GD Suresh Kumar.

¶3Ex. No. 134456A Rifleman/GD Satish Kumar Shukla.

¶4Ex. No. 134467 Rifleman/Gd Abdul Salam. K.S.

¶5Ex. No. 350079P Havildar.GD Anand Pal Singh.

¶6Ex. No. 134436 Havildar/GD Sarfraj Ansari.

¶7Ex. No. 134469 Rifleman/GD Harpal Singh.

¶8Ex. No. 153750 Havildar/GD Alex C B.

¶9Ex. No. 153743 Havildar/GD Gopakumar D.

¶10Ex.No. 153746 Havildar/GD 153746.

¶11Ex. No. 134445 Havildar.GD Budhwa Guria.

¶12Smt. Sushela Chamoli.

1.

2.

¶3The Commandant, 13th Assam Rifles C/o 99APO, Pin – 932013.

¶4The Commandant, 15th Assam Rifles C/o 99APO, Pin-932015.

: WP(C). No. 182 of 2022

¶1Ex. No. 134451F, Havildar/GD Nandu Lal.

¶2Ex. No. G/153738N Havildar/GD Ramniwas.

1.

2.

: WP(C). No. 45 of 2023

¶1No. G/184568, Havildar/GD Rabin Kumar Limbu.

¶2No. AR-415P Assistant Commandant, Sukraj Rai.

¶3No. –G/95872 Havildar/GD B.Dkhumba Yimchunger.

1.

2.

¶3The Commandant, 9th Assam Rifles C/o 99APO, Pin – 932009.

¶4The Commandant, 18th Assam Rifles C/o 99APO, Pin-932018.

: ORAL

¶1In these batch of matters, in view of the judgment dated 28-08-2023, passed by the Supreme Court in Special Leave Petition (Civil) Diary No(s). 39888/2022, nothing remains for consideration.

¶2Mr. B.Pathak, learned counsel however, has vehemently argued that for the period that the writ petitioners have served in the clerical grade, due consideration should have been given. However, on examination of the order passed by the Division Bench in WA. No. 18 of 2019, this aspect is also covered which disentitles the writ petitioners from claiming any benefits that came with the clerical post.

¶3Accordingly, these matters stand closed and disposed of. Chief Justice (Acting) Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org) Date: 2024.08.22 17:15:34 IST