Radhey Shyam Singh v. Shri Surendra Tiwari Presently Posted As Secretary, Basic Education Parishad

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD CONTEMPT APPLICATION (CIVIL) No. - 3875 of 2026 Court No. - 53 HON'BLE VIKAS BUDHWAR, J.

¶1On the oral request of the counsel for the applicant, he is permitted to implead Mr. Devi Prasad Pal (Chairman), Chief Development Officer, Chitrakoot, as opposite party no. 2 during the course of the day.

¶2The present contempt application has been preferred alleging willful defiance of the order dated 03.12.2025 passed in Writ-A No. 18255 of 2025, order whereof is quoted hereunder:- "1. Heard learned counsel for the petitioner. Learned Standing Counsel has accepted notice on behalf of respondents no.1, 2, 4 & 5, Sri Shivendra Kumar Singh, learned counsel has accepted notice on behalf of respondent no.3 and Sri Dinesh Chandra Kesarwani, learned counsel has accepted notice on behalf of respondent nos.2 & 4.

¶2The final list of selection for the post of Academic Resource Person (ARP) dated

12.11.2025 in so far as it relates to selection of respondent no.6 is concerned is under challenge in the present writ petition.

¶3It is argued by counsel for the petitioner that respondent no.6 is not qualified for his appointment on the aforesaid post in view of the Government Order dated 22.10.2019. In paragraph-18 of the writ petition it is stated that respondent no.6 is B-Tech hence he is not eligible for applying for the aforesaid post.

¶4Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the records.

¶5From perusal of the records it transpires that petitioner is aggrieved against the selection of the respondent no.6 on the aforesaid post on the ground that he is not qualified for the aforesaid post.

¶6After hearing counsel for the parties and after perusal of the records, the Court is Versus Counsel for Applicant(s) : Rishabh Kumar Pandey, Yog Maya Gautam Counsel for Opposite Party(s) : Yatindra Radhey Shyam Singh .....Applicant(s) Shri Surendra Tiwari Presently Posted As Secretary, Basic Education Parishad .....Opposite Party(s) of the opinion that this factual controversy could not be resolved by this Court specially under Article 226 Constitution of India.

¶7In the facts and circumstances, petitioner is permitted to submit a fresh representation ventilating all his grievances before the respondent no.2-Secretary, Basic Shiksha Parishad, U.P., Prayagraj along-with certified copy of this order within a period of two weeks from today. If such a representation is made, the respondent no.2 is directed to pass appropriate order in accordance with law after providing opportunity of hearing to the respondent no.6 within next six weeks from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order.

¶8With the aforesaid observations, present writ petition is disposed of finally.

¶9Since the writ petition has been decided on an exparte version without seeking any response from the respondents, thus the passing of the order today may not be construed to an expression that this Court has gone into the merits of the matter and the second respondent shall accord independent consideration strictly in accordance with law and the mandate of law holding the field."

¶3This Court on 07.07.2026 proceeded to pass the following order:- "Let a copy of the contempt application be served upon Sri Brijesh Kumar, learned Standing Counsel who shall seek instructions. Put up this case on 04.08.2026 as fresh."

¶4Thereafter on 04.08.2026 the following order was passed:- "Sri Brijesh Kumar, learned Standing Counsel submits that a letter has been sent for seeking instructions but he has not received instructions. Put up this case on 21.08.2026 as fresh, by which time, he shall obtain instructions."

¶5On 21.08.2026 following order was passed:- "1. Let a copy of the contempt application be served upon Sri Yatindra (AoR No. A/Y 0026/2012), who appear for the opposite party, during the course of the day.

¶2Put up this case on 14.09.2026, as fresh.

¶3When the case is next listed, name of Sri Yatindra be shown from the opposite side."

¶6On 14.09.2026, following order was passed:- "1. Today, when the matter has been taken up, Sri Yatindra, learned counsel, submits that the opposite party has passed an order dated 02.09.2026, according to which, respondent no. 5 in Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 18255 of 2025, District Selection Committee, Academic Resource Person (ARP), Chitrakoot, is the competent person to decide the claim.

¶2On being asked as to from which source the same can be determined, Sri Yatindra submits that it is as per the Government Order dated 22.10.2019.

¶3Sri Yatindra was asked to place the Government Order dated 22.10.2019 before this Court but he is not in possession of the same.

¶4Put up this case on 30.09.2026 as fresh, by which time the said Government Order shall be placed before this Court.

¶5The order dated 02.09.2026 is taken on record and shall be marked as Appendix 'A'."

¶7In the order dated 14.09.2026, Sri Yatindra who was served with the copy of the contempt petition had produced before this Court an order dated 02.09.2026 of the opposite party no.2 who happens to be Secretary, Basic Education Parishad, U.P. at Prayagraj, wherein a stand had been taken that with respect to the grievances so raised by the applicant relating to Academic Resource Person (ARP), the same is to be decided by a Committee, which comprises of five officers being: (1) Chief Development Officer - Chairman, (2) Principal, District DIET - Member,

(3) District Basic Education Officer - Secretary / Member, (4) District Coordinator (Training) - Member, (5) Senior Block Education Officer - Member.

¶8Today, Government Order has been produced dated 22.10.2019 so as to show that the opposite party being the Secretary of the Basic Education Parishad, U.P. at Prayagraj is not concerned for taking a decision and the Committee is to take a decision.

¶9I have heard the counsels for the parties and perused the record carefully.

¶10The order of the Writ Court accorded liberty to the applicant to file a fresh representation before the respondent no. 2, Secretary, Basic Shiksha Parishad, U.P. Prayagraj along with the certified copy of the order and the said authority being opposite party herein was to decide the same after hearing the respondent no.6 i.e. Deepak Kumar Gupta, Assistant Teacher, within a period of six weeks from the date of receipt of the order.

¶11The allegation of the applicant is that despite filing of representation, the same has not been decided. The array of parties in the writ petition in so far as respondents are concerned is quoted hereunder:- "1. State of U.P. through its Principal Secretary, Basic Education, Government of U.P. at Lucknow.

¶2Secretary, Basic Shiksha Parishad, Uttar Pradesh at Prayagraj.

¶3Director, School Shiksha Evam Rajya Pariyojana Nideshak, Vidhya Bhawan, Nishantganj, Lucknow.

¶4District Basic Education Officer, District Chitrakoot.

¶5District Selection Committee Academic Resource Person (ARP), Chitrakoot.6. Deepak Kumar Gupta, Assistant Teacher, Selected candidate for ARP working as Assistant Teacher in Primary School, Tamrar, Ram Nagar, Chitrakoot. ....Respondents"

¶12A bare look at paragraph no.1 of the judgment and order of the Writ Court dated 03.12.2025 would go to show that learned Standing Counsel appeared for Principal Secretary, Basic Education, Government of U.P., Lucknow /Respondent No.1, Secretary, Basic Shiksha Parishad, Uttar Pradesh at Prayagraj/Respondent No.2, District Basic Education Officer, District Chitrakoot/Respondent No.4, and District Selection Committee, Academic Resource Person (ARP), Chitrakoot was represented by learned Standing Counsel and Sri Shivendra Kumar Singh appeared for Director, School Shiksha and State Project Director, Vidya Bhawan, Nishadganj, Lucknow and Sri Dinesh Chand Kesarwani for Secretary, Basic Shiksha Parishad, Uttar Pradesh at Prayagraj and District Basic Education Officer, District Chitrakoot.

¶13Interestingly, notice on behalf of Secretary, Basic Shiksha Parishad, Uttar Pradesh at Prayagraj and District Basic Education Officer, District Chitrakoot was received by learned Standing Counsel as well as by Sri Dinesh Chand Kesarwani.

¶14On 02.09.2026, an order came to be passed by the opposite party, Secretary, Basic Education Parishad, U.P. at Prayagraj, who happened to be Respondent No.2 in the writ petition, whereby a stand was taken that the Committee so constituted as per the Government Order dated

22.10.2019 is to decide the said issue. For ready reference, the order dated

02.09.2026 is quoted hereunder:-"मा0 उच्च न्यायालय में योजित याचिका संख्या 18255/2025 राधेश्याम सिंह बनाम उत्तर प्रदेश राज्य एवं 05 अन्य में पारित आदेश दिनांक 03.12.2025 के अनुपालन में याची द्वारा प्रस्तुत अपील का निस्तारण :-श्री राधे श्याम सिंह सहायक अध्यापक कन्या उच्च प्राथमिक विद्यालय रूपौली क्षेत्र रामनगर जनपद चित्रकूट द्वारा मा0 उच्च न्यायालय में योजित याचिका संख्या 18255/2025 राधेश्याम सिंह बनाम उत्तर प्रदेश राज्य एवं 05 अन्य में पारित आदेश दिनांक 03.12.2025 के अनुपालन में अपने अपील के साथ संलग्न कर प्रस्तुत की गयी। जिसमें मा0 न्यायालय द्वारा निम्नवत आदेश पारित किये गये है :-

¶1Heard learned counsel for the petitioner. Learned Standing Counsel has accepted notice on behalf of respondents no.1, 2, 4 & 5, Sri Shivendra Kumar Singh, learned counsel has accepted notice on behalf of respondent no.3 and Sri Dinesh Chandra Kesarwani, learned counsel has accepted notice on behalf of respondent nos.2 & 4.

¶2The final list of selection for the post of Academic Resource Person (ARP) dated 12.11.2025 in so far as it relates to selection of respondent no.6 is concerned is under challenge in the present writ petition.

¶3It is argued by counsel for the petitioner that respondent no.6 is not qualified for his appointment on the aforesaid post in view of the Government Order dated 22.10.2019. In paragraph-18 of the writ petition it is stated that respondent no.6 is B-Tech hence he is not eligible for applying for the aforesaid post.

¶4Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the records.

¶5From perusal of the records it transpires that petitioner is aggrieved against the selection of the respondent no.6 on the aforesaid post on the ground that he is not qualified for the aforesaid post. 6. After hearing counsel for the parties and after perusal of the records, the Court is of the opinion that this factual controversy could not be resolved by this Court specially under Article 226 Constitution of India. Versus Counsel for Petitioner(s) : Agnihotri Kumar Tripathi Counsel for Respondent(s) : C.S.C., Shiv Raj Singh Radhey Shyam Singh .....Petitioner(s) State Of U.P. And 5 Others .....Respondent(s)

¶7In the facts and circumstances, petitioner is permitted to submit a fresh representation ventilating all his grievances before the respondent no.2-Secretary, Basic Shiksha Parishad, U.P., Prayagraj along-with certified copy of this order within a period of two weeks from today. If such a representation is made, the respondent no.2 is directed to pass appropriate order in accordance with law after providing opportunity of hearing to the respondent no.6 within next six weeks from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order.

¶8With the aforesaid observations, present writ petition is disposed of finally.

¶9Since the writ petition has been decided on an exparte version without seeking any response from the respondents, thus the passing of the order today may not be construed to an expression that this Court has gone into the merits of the matter and the second respondent shall accord independent consideration strictly in accordance with law and the mandate of law holding the field. ्र करणाके ािनस् तारणाहते ुापिरषदाकायार्लयाके ाप्र ासंख् यााबे0िश0प0/21968-69/2025-26ािदनांका

20.02.2026ा्व ाराासुनवाईाकीाितिथा12.03.2026ािनधािर् रताकरतेाहु येािजलााबेिसकािश्ष ााअिधकारीा िच्र कू टाकोा्र करणासेासम् बिन् धताआख् याातथााअपीलाथर् ाकोाअपनााप्ष ा्र स् तुतािकयेाजानेाके ािनदर्शािदयेागये। अपीलाथर् ाउपिस् थताहु येाऔराअपनााप्ष ा्र स् तुतािकयाागयाातथाािजलााबेिसकािश्ष ााअिधकारीाके ा ्र ितिनिधा्र ीाएन0पी0ािसहाखण् डािश्ष ााअिधकारीािवकासाखण् डारामनगरािच्र कू टा्व ारााआख् यााप्र ांका 11455-458/2025-26ािदनांका10.03.2026ा्र स् तुतािकयाागया। अपीलाथर् ा्व ारााअनुरोधािकयाागयााहाै िका्र ाथर् ा्व ारााए0आर0पी0ा(िव्ञ ान)ाचयनाजनपदािच्र कू टाके ा सम् बन् धामेंाउपयुर्त ावादामेंामा0ाउच् चान् यायालया्व ाराािदनांका03.12.2025ाकोापािरताआदेशाके ाअनुपालनाथर्ा यहाअिन् तमाअ?् यावेदना्र स् तुतािकयााजाारहााह।ै ामा0ान् यायालयानेा्र ितवादीासंख् या-2ाकोािनदर्िशतािकयाागयाा हाै िका्र ाथर् ाके ाअ?् यावेदनापरािवचाराकराकारणायु्त ाआदेशापािरताकरें।ा्र करणाके ातथ् याएवंाचयना्र िक्र याामेंा हु ईागम् भीराअवैधतायेंाह।ैं 1- ्र ाथर् ाकीािव्ञ ानािवषयायोग् यतााएवंाचयिनताअ?् यथर् ा्र ीादीपकाकु मारागुप् तााकीाअयोग् यताा:-ा्र ाथर् ा बी0एस0सी0ा(वनस् पितािव्ञ ान,ाजन् तुािव्ञ ान,ारसायनािव्ञ ान)ास् नातकाह,ै ाजोाए0आर0पी0ािव्ञ ानाहते ुा अपेि्ष तािवषयािवशेष्ञ तााके ापूणर्तःाअनुरू पाह।ै ाजबािकािजलााबेिसकािश्ष ााअिधकारी,ािच्र कू टाके ाआदेशा प्र ाकं ा/7072-79/2025-26ािदनांका12.11.2025ाके ाक्र मासंख् याा02ाचयिनताअ?् यथर् ा्र ीादीपकाकु मारा गुप् तााबी0टके 0ा(इंजीिनय?रग)ाधारकाह।ै ाजोाशासनादेशा22.10.2019ाके ाअनुसारािव्ञ ानािवषयािवशेष्ञ ताा कीा्र ेणीामेंानहीं ाआतेाह।ैं ाअतःाअयोग् याअ?् यथर् ाकााचयनािनयमािवरु द्ध ाह,ै ाएवंािजलााबेिसकािश्ष ााअिधकारी,ा िच्र कू टाके ाआदेशाप्र ाकं ागुण0/िव0/5719-25/2025-26ािदनांका04.10.2025ाके ाक्र मासंख् या-6ापरा अिभमन् युािसहाकीायोग् यताास् नातकापी0सी0एम0ासेाह।ै ाजबािकाशासनादेशा22.10.2019ामेंािव्ञ ाना ए0आर0पी0ापदाहते ुास् नातकाबी0एस0सी0ाजन् तु,ावनस् पिताएवंारसायनािव्ञ ानाअहतर् ााह।ै 2- ्र ाथर् ा्व ाराादोाबारािलिखताएवंामाइक्र ो-टी?चगाउत् ीणर्ा-ा्र ाथर् ानेाए0आर0पी0ाचयना्र िक्र याामेंादोनोाअवसरों ा परािलिखतापरी्ष ाा60ा्र ितशतासेाअिधकामाइक्र ो-टी?चगा60ा्र ितशतासेाअिधकाअंका्र ाप् ताकराउत् ीणर्ािकयाा जोाउनकीािवषया्ष मतााएवंापा्र ताािसद्ध ाकरतााह।ै 3-के वलासा्ष ात् कारामेंामनमानेाअंकादेकराअपा्र ाघोिषतािकयााजानाा-ादोनोाअवसरों ापरा्र ाथर् ाकोाके वला सा्ष ात् कारामेंा46ा्र ितशतासेाकमाअंकादेकराअनुत् ीणर्ाघोिषतािकयाागया,ाजबािकावहािलिखताएवंामाइक्र ो- टी?चगामेंास्ष मापायाागया।ायहाचयना्र िक्र याामेंा्य ि्त परकता,ाप्ष पाताएवंामनमानेामूल् यांकनाकाासंके ताह।ै 4-शासनादेशा22.10.2019ाके ािविडयोािरका?डगा्र ावधानाकााउल् लंघन-ाशासनादेशाके ाअनुसारािलिखता माइक्र ो-टी?चगा एवंा सा्ष ात् कारा कीा िविडयोा िरका?डगा करायीा हीा नहीं ा गयी।ा अतःा सा्ष ात् कारा अंकना कीा पारदिशताासमाप् ताहोागयीातथााचयना्र िक्र यााकाासत् यापनाअसम् भवाहोागया।ािजससेासम् पूणर्ाचयना्र िक्र याा संदेहास् पदाएवंादू िषताहोागयी। 5- िलिखतामाइक्र ो-टी?चगाअंकाएवंासा्ष ात् काराके ाअंकाघोिषतानािकयााजाना-ा्र ाथर् ाकोानातोािलिखतापरी्ष ाा एवंानाहीामाइक्र ो-टी?चगाके ाअंकािकसीास् तरापराघोिषताअथवााउपलब् धाकरायेागये।ासा्ष ात् काराअंकाभीािकसीा अिभलेखायााप्र ाके ामाध् यमासेानादेकराके वलामौिखकारू पासेालगभगा46ा्र ितशताबतायेागये।ाअतःाअंका ्र िक्र यााअपारदशर् ाह,ै ाजोाचयना्र िक्र यााकोाअवैधाएवंाअिव्व सनीयाबनातााह।ै 6- िव्ञ िप् तामेंािबन् दु ासंख् या-23ाकााअवैधासमावेश-ाकायार्लयािजलााबेिसकािश्ष ााअिधकारीािच्र कू टाके ा िव्ञ िप् ताआदेशाप्र ाकं ा2428-34/2025-26ािदनांका04.07.2025ाके ािबन् दु ा23ा्र थमाचयनामेंा्र ाथर् ाकोा सा्ष ात् कारामेंाअनुत् ीणर्ाकरनेाके ापश्च ातािर्त ापदों ाहते ुाजारीािव्ञ िप् तामेंािजलााबेिसकािश्ष ााअिधकारीािच्र कू टा ्व ाराािबन् दु ा23ाजोड़ ाागयाािकापूवर्ापरी्ष ाामेंाअसफलाअ?् यथर् ाआवेदनाके ापा्र ानहीं ाहों गे।ाजबािकाशासनादेशा

22.10.2019ामेंाऐसााकोईा्र ितबन् धानहीं ाहाै िजलाास् तरापरापा्र तााशतर्ाजोड़ नााअिधकारा्ष े्र ासेाबाहराह।ै ा अतःाउ्त ाशतर्ाअवैधाएवंाशून् याह।ै 7-चयना्र िक्र यााकीासम्र ाअवैधतााउपरो्त ातथ् यों ासेास् प्ट ाहाै िकाअयोग् याअ?् यथर् ाकााचयन,ासा्ष ात् कारामेंा मनमानााअंकन,ािविडयोािरका?डगा्र ावधानाउल् लंघन,ाअंकाघोिषतानाकरना,ािव्ञ िप् तामेंाअवैधापा्र ताा्र ितबन् धा के ाकारणाए०आर०पी०(िव्ञ ान)ाचयना्र िक्र याापूणर्तःादू िषताअपारदशर् ाएवंािनयमािवरु द्ध ाह।ै याचीा्व ारााबी०टके ाअ?् यथर् ा्र ीादीपकाकु मारागुप् तााके ाचयनाकोाअयोग् यतााके ाआधारापरािनरस् तािकयाा जाय।ा्र ाथर् ाके ािलिखताएवंामाइक्र ो-टी?चगामेिरटाके ाआधारापरापा्र ताापरािवचारािकयााजाय।ाअवैधािबन् दु ा23ा कोािनरस् तािकयेाजाय।ा्र ाथर् ाकोाए०आर०पी०ािव्ञ ानापदापरािनयमानुसाराचयिनतािकयेाजानेाकााअनुरोधा िकयाागयााह।ै िजलाा बेिसका िश्ष ाा अिधकारीा िच्र कू टा नेा आख् याा प्र ांका 11455-458/2025-26ा िदनांका

10.03.2026ा ्व ाराा अवगता करायाा गयाा हाै िका शासनादेशा संख् या-68-5099/143/2024-अनुभाग-5ा िदनांका10ाअक् टूबरा2024ाएवंाशासनादेशासंख् या-902/68-5-2019ािदनांका22ाअक् टूबरा2019ाके ा अनुपालना मेंा महािनदेशक,ा स् कू ला िश्ष ाा एवंा राज् या पिरयोजनाा िनदेशक,ा सम्र ा िश्ष ा,ा उ०्र ०ा लखनऊा के ा प्र ाकं /गु०िव०/ए०आर०पी०/9333/ा2024-25ािदनांका15.01.2025ाके ा्व ाराासम्र ािश्ष ााके ाअन् तगर्ता स् थािपतान् यायापंचायतासंसाधनाके न् ्र ों ाएवंाब् लॉकासंसाधनाके न् ्र ों ाके ापुनगर्ठनाहते ुािनगर्ताशासनादेशाके ाक्र मामेंा अकादिमकािरसोसर्ापसर्ना(ए०आर०पी०)ाचयनाके ासम् बन् धामेंािनदर्शा्र दानािकयेागयेाह।ै शासनादेशा िदनांका 22ा अक् टबरा 2019ा मेंा िनिहता ्य वस् थानुसारा अकादिमका िरसोसर्ा पसर्नाू (ए०आर०पी०)ाचयनाकीाकायर्वाहीाजनपदीयाचयनासिमिताके ाअध् य्ष -मुख् यािवकासाअिधकारी,ािच्र कू टाके ा अनुमोदनािदनांका12.02.2025ाके ाक्र मामेंाजनपदाके ासमस् तािवकासखण् डाहते ुा25ाअकादिमकािरसोसर्ापसर्ना (ए०आर०पी०)ा के ा पदा कोा भरेंा जानेा हते ुा अधोहस् ता्ष रीा कायार्लया प्र ांक/9134-42/2024-25ा िदनांका

05.03.2025ा के ा ्व ाराा िव्ञ िप् ता ्र काशना कीा कायर्वाहीा कीा गयी।ा िजसमेंा ्र ीा राधेश् यामा िसह,ा स०अ०,ा उ०्र ा०िव०ारू पौली,ा्ष े्र -रामनगरा्व ारााआवेदनािकयाागया।ाशासनादेशाके ाअनुपालनामेंािलिखतापरी्ष ाावा माइक्र ोाटी?चगाकीाकायर्वाहीाकीागयी,ािजसमेंा्र ीाराधेश् यामािलिखतापरी्ष ाावामाइक्र ोाटी?चगामेंाअहार् पायेागयेा िकन् तुासा्ष ात् कारामेंाजनपदीयासिमिता्व ाराािदयेागयेाअंकों ाके ाआधारापरा्र ीाराधेश् यामाकोाअनहार् घोिषतािकयाा गया।ाचयना्र िक्र याामेंाकु ला25ापदों ाके ासापे्ष ा13ाअकादिमकािरसोसर्ापसर्ना(ए०आर०पी०)ाकााचयिनताहु ये। पुनश्च ािर्त ा12ापदों ाहते ुामुख् यािवकासाअिधकारी,ािच्र कू टाके ाअनुमोदनािदनांका02.07.2025ाके ा अनुपालनामेंाचयनाकीाकायर्वाहीाकीागयी,ाइसा्र िक्र याामेंाभीा्र ीाराधेश् यामािलिखतापरी्ष ाावामाइक्र ोाटी?चगामेंा अहार् पायाे गयेािकन् तुासा्ष ात् कारामेंाजनपदीयासिमिता्व ाराािदयेागयेाअंकों ाके ाआधारापरा्र ीाराधेश् यामाकोाअनहार् घोिषता िकयाा गया।ा चयना ्र िक्र याा मेंा िर्त ा कु ला 12ा पदों ा के ा सापे्ष ा 05ा अकादिमका िरसोसर्ा पसर्ना (ए०आर०पी०)ाकााचयिनताहु ये।ािर्त ा07ापदों ाकीाचयनाकीाकायर्वाहीागितमानाह।ै उ्त ाके ाअितिर्त ायाचीा्र ीाराधेश् यामािसहा्व ाराामा०ाउच् चान् यायालयामेंायोिजतायािचकाासंख् या- 18255/2025ामेंा्र ाथर्नााकीागयीाहाै िका्र ीादीपकागुप् ता,ास०अ०,ा्र ा०िव०ातमरा,ा्ष े्र ावाजनपद-िच्र कू टा जोाबी०टके ाहाै कााचयनाअकादिमकािरसोसर्ापसर्ना(ए०आर०पी०)ामेंािकयाागयााह,ै ाजोािकाशासनादेशािदनांका 22ाअक् टूबरा2019ामेंाउिल् लिखतािनिहता्र ािवधानों ाके ािवपरीताह,ै ाके ासम् बन् धामेंास् प्ट ाकरनााहाै िकाबेिसका िश्ष ाािवभागाके ाअन् तगर्ताकायर् तािश्ष कों ाहते ुाक्र मशःामा्र ा04ािवषयाहाै :-ागिणत-िव्ञ ान,ासामािजकािवषय,ा भाषाािहन् दी,ाभाषााअं्र ेजीाह,ै ािजसमेंागिणतावािव्ञ ानािवषयासेास् नातकाकरनेावालेािश्ष कों ाकोागिणत-िव्ञ ाना िवषयामेंारखाागयााह,ै ािजससेा्र ीादीपकागुप् तााभीागिणत-िव्ञ ानािवषयाके ािश्ष कासेाआच् छािदताह।ै ािजसके ा दृ ि्ट गताजनपदीयाचयनासिमिता्व ाराा्र ीादीपकागुप् तााकोािव्ञ ानािवषयाके ारू पामेंाअकादिमकािरसोसर्ापसर्ना (ए0आर0पी0)ामेंाचयिनतािकयाागयााह।ै िजलााबेिसकािश्ष ााअिधकारीाकीाआख् याातथाायाचीा्र ीाराधेश् यामािसहा्व ाराा्र स् तुताअिभलेखाके ा अनुशीलना सेा स् प्ट ा हाै िका ्र ीा राधेश् यामा िसहा ्व ाराा अकादिमका िरसोसर्ा पसर्ना (ए0आर0पी0)ा चयना मेंा अिनयिमततााआिदाके ासम् बन् धामेंािशकायताकीागयीाह।ै ाअकादिमकािरसोसर्ापसर्ना(ए0आर0पी0)ाचयनाकीा कायर्वाहीाकााअिधकारा्ष े्र ाइसाकायार्लयामेंािनिहतानहीं ाह।ै ाअतःा्र करणापराइसाकायार्लया्व ाराािनणर्यानहीं ा िलयााजाासकतााह।ै ्र ीाराधेाश् यामािसहासहायकाअध् यापकाकन् यााउच् चा्र ाथिमकािवद्य ालयारू पौलीा्ष े्र ारामनगराजनपदा िच्र कू टा्व ाराा्र स् तुता्र त् यावेदनाउपरो्त ानुसारािनस् तािरतािकयााजातााह।ै (सुरेन् ्र ाकु माराितवारी) सिचव उ0्र 0ाबेिसकािश्ष ाापिरषद, ्र यागराज।"

¶15Further, Para 4 sub-clause 3 and 4 of the Government Order dated 22nd October, 2019 containing the heading "सम्र ािश्ष ााअिभयानाके ाअन् तगर्ता स् थािपतान् यायापंचायतासंसाधनाके न् ्र ों ाएवंाब् लॉकासंसाधनाके न् ्र ों ाके ासंबंधामें"ाis quoted hereunder:- "4-न् यायापंचायतासंसाधनाके न् ?्र ों ाएवंा?् लाकासंसाधनाके न् ?्र ों ाके ापुनगर्ठनाके ासंबंधामेंािनम् नवतािनद?र्शािदयेा जातेाह?ैं - ....

(3) चयनाप्र ि?्र या?- िश्ष कासाथीाके ाचयनाहते ुा्र िति्ठ तान् यूनतमा02ासमाचाराप्र ों ामेंािव्ञ िप् ताकाा्र काशनािकयाा जायेगा।ािव्ञ िप् तामेंाआवेदनाहते ुाउिल् लिखतािवषयाकोास् प्ट ािकयााजाये।

(4) Academic Resource Person (ARP) के ाचयनाहते ुाजनपदीयाचयनासिमितािनम् नवताहोगी?- 1-मुख् यािवकासाअिधकारी,ााााााााााााााााााााााााााअध् य्ष 2-्र ाचायर्,ािजलाािश्ष ााएवंा्र िश्ष णासंस् थानााासदस् य 3-िजलााबिे सकािश्ष ााअिधकारीााााााााााााााााासदस् य-सिचव 4-िजलाासमन् वयका(्र िश्ष ण)ााााााााााााााााााााासदस् य 5-विर्ठ ाखण् डािश्ष ााअिधकारीाााााााााााााााााााााासदस् य"

¶16A perusal of the Government Order dated 20.10.2019 would reveal that with respect to Academic Resource Person (ARP), a committee has been constituted, which comprises of 5 members and the opposite parties not the members.

¶17At this stage, Sri Yatindra, as per the instruction received from the client, submits that the representations so preferred by the applicant before the opposite party shall be transmitted to the said committee, which shall decide the said matter.

¶18Accordingly, without going further, the contempt application stand disposed of requiring the opposite party in the present contempt petition to transmit the entire papers/ representation so submitted by the applicant by 09.10.2026 and the District Selection Committee, Academic Resource Person (ARP) Chitrakoot through its Chairman, who was already a party in the writ petition as respondent no. 5, being opposite party no. 2 in the contempt application, shall decide the same within a period of 6 weeks. Liberty is accorded to the applicant to again approach this Court as and when the situation arises.

¶19The Government Order dated 20.10.2019 is taken on record and marked as Appendix B. September 30, 2026 N.S.Rathour (Vikas Budhwar,J.) High Court of Judicature at Allahabad