Phool Singh v. Rajinder Singh & Ors

V.B.GUPTA, J. rb

* HIGH COURT OF DELHI : NEW DELHI FAO No.47/2009 & CM No. 2539/2009 % Judgment reserved on: 26th August, 2009 Judgment delivered on: 11th September, 2009 Sh. Phool Singh, S/o Shri Pema, R/o Khasra No. 50/01, Village Himayun Pur, New Delhi-29 ….Appellant Through: Mr. Naresh K. Thanai with Mr. Puneet Sharma, Advs. Versus (1) Sh. Rajinder Singh S/o Late Sh. Khem Chand (2) Sh. Sat Prakash S/o Late Sh. Khem Chand (3) Sh. Satbir Singh S/o Late Sh. Khem Chand (4) Smt. Vimla W/o Chand Ram D/o Late Sh. Khem Chand. (5) Smt. Kamla W/o Anoop Singh D/o Late Sh. Khem Chand. (6) Smt. Santosh W/o Satbir D/o Late Sh. Khem Chand. All R/o 60-B, Himayun Pur, New Delhi-110029. (7) Smt. Jeeto W/o Late Sh. Bhoru (8) Shri Sher Singh S/o Late Sh. Bhoru (9) Sh. Sri Bhagwan S/o Late Sh. Bhoru (10) Sh. Jai Bhagwan S/o Late Sh. Bhoru (11) Smt. Shanti W/o Shri Wazir D/o Late Shri Bhoru (12) Smt. Om Wati, W/o Raj Kumar D/o Late Shri Bhoru All R/o 60-B, Himayun Pur, Delhi-29 (13) Sh. Dalip Kumar S/o Late Sh. Hukum Chand. (14) Smt. Nirmla Devi, W/o Shri Pratap Singh Chikara D/o Late Shri Hukum Chand. (15) Smt. Krishna, W/o Sh. Sumer Singh Chikara D/o Late Shri Hukum Chand. (16) Smt. Bhagwati, W/o Shri Mahinder D/o Late Shri Hukum Chand All R/o 60-B, Himayun Pur, New Delhi-110029. (17) Smt. Roshni, Wd/o Late Sh. Darshan. (18) Sh. Jagbir, S/o Late Sh. Darshan. (19) Sh. Kuldeep, S/o Late Sh. Darshan. (20) Sh. Balraj, S/o Late Sh. Darshan. (21) Smt. Savita, W/o Sh. Ram Avtar D/o Late Shri Darshan. (22) Miss Suman (Minor) (aged about 15 years) D/o Late Sh. Darshan. Through her mother, Smt. Roshni (the Pltf. No. 17) as her next friend. All R/o 60-B, Himayun Pur, New Delhi-110029. (23) Smt. Ram Kumari, D/o Late Shri Chander Bhan. (24) Sh. Chattar Singh, D/o Late Shri Chander Bhan. (25) Smt. Laxmi @ Babli, W/o Shri Jaipal, D/o Late Shri Chander Bhan. All R/o 60-B, Himayun Pur, New Delhi-110029. (26) Sh. Jagdev, S/o Shri Juglal, (deceased through L. R."s) a. Smt. Rati Devi, W/o Sh. Jagdev b. Smt. Santosh, Wd./o Late Sh. Raj Kumar. c. Sh. Jai Karan, S/o Raj Kumar All R/o 72, Himayun Pur, New Delhi-110029. (27) Smt. Chhoto Wd./o Late Shri Balbir Singh (28) Sh. Narain Singh S/o Late Shri Balbir Singh. (29) Smt. Shushma W/o Late Shri Rambir Singh D/o late Shri Balbir Singh (30) Smt. Seema W/o Late Shri Rakesh D/o late Shri Balbir Singh (31) Sh. Rajinder S/o Late Shri Khuba (32) Smt. Panmeshwari S/o Late Shri Khuba (33) Smt. Phool Kaur S/o Late Shri Khuba All R/o 77, Himayun Pur, New Delhi-110029. (34) Smt. Dhan Kaur @ Dhanno Wd/o Late Shri Balram @ Balbir Singh (35) Sh. Jai Singh S/o Late Shri Balram @ Balbir Singh (36) Sh. Subhash S/o Late Shri Balram @ Balbir Singh (37) Smt. Roshni W/o Sh. Ramphal D/o Late Shri Balram @ Balbir Singh All R/o 77, Himayun Pur, New Delhi-110029. (38) Smt. Nirmla Devi Wd./o Late Sh. Ram Kishan (39) Sh. Vikram Singh S/o Late Sh. Ram Kishan (40) Sh. Virender S/o Late Sh. Ram Kishan (41) Smt. Savita D/o Late Sh. Ram Kishan All R/o 77-B, Himayun Pur, New Delhi-110029. (42) Sh. Mukhtiar Singh S/o Late Sh. Ganga Dass (43) Sh. Lakhpat Singh S/o Late Sh. Jai Ram (44) Sh. Chatar Singh @ Chatre S/o Late Sh. Jai Ram (45) Smt. Risalo Wd./o Late Sh. Jai Ram (46) Smt. Dhanpati D/o Late Sh. Jai Ram (47) Smt. Roshani D/o Late Sh. Om Prakash (48) Smt. Risalo D/o Late Sh. Om Prakash All R/o Village Himayun Pur, New Delhi-110029. (49) Shri Tejhbir Singh @ Teju S/o Late Sh. Khazan Singh (deceased through L. R. "s) (a) Smt . Ram Kaur W/o Sh. Khazan Singh (b) Smt. Manoranjana W/o Sh. Tejbir Singh (c) Sh. Amit S/o Sh. Tejbir Singh (d) Sh. Ashish S/o Sh. Tejbir Singh (e) Sh. Aman S/o Sh. Tejbir Singh All R/o Himayun Pur, New Delhi-110029. ….Respondents. Through: Mr. S.S. Panwar with Mr. Sunil Dutt, Advs. Coram: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.B. GUPTA 1. Whether the Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes 2. To be referred to Reporter or not? Yes 3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Yes V.B.Gupta, J. This appeal is against order