Suraj Dev Paswan v. Ndmc

HIMA KOHLI, J. For detailed judgment, see WP(C) No.4743/2011. The Registry is directed to place a copy of the judgment passed in WP(C) No.4743/20'11 In thIs ffte.··- OCTOER 24th 2011 , rkb W.P.(C) 4347/2011 and connected matters ----,,--_. (HIMA KOHLI) JUDGE Page 8 of8 ,., /,' I ! I ' / J; !",: >,' J /1 J" , 'J: i J !!... :, '" i " ',l !, I ( / i, .I' " ,"~ , t,.' ,! ,', 'y I 1(11"/ / {,1~K If f 'l-I\ {<;", /",;n Ir r: 'l\!',!II{ /' ,(1\.,,\'\1,1' '\\11 1(\1/'/ ilHll f: .~ 1(\'1\,,' / 'I: 'f: 'f;; ,1)1 '\\ \C {lll,( / f\J \I' C ';, 'II 'II' «.rt ! f' J l i~ 11 '11 "II':' / '('I'll'; II :c. , Ii ~ I' \1)' /'.i "I "~ii fl/ , 1\ 'II I ~ t ! '! r r~ rb '\('1\ fli't / t),,'-:'(;i,fj; "\\\ll(\J~t': \v~ '·,;"Y )'~ ll\ y'J': ! {f.r: ,'-;; 'I) ''II ~r II'U'/' / ,{.,',{ ,r; of;J '11 ~'{!'~/ / l .i '{ ,Ill ' I! 1 If» :r'! n"I? 'r~; , II ~'«11 (, ,: 'fft II';; ')1 "h 1 ij il r /' I(~ 'I,; /:-'1:1 ',~ 1\ 11';1'/ /1(llt,l'(,!1 'll l\'i~'-i:/<;ll"ll '1! II I\!i ,; ,I l\ It \) "\\'t)) , II' III \, ,j" / ~';) fU II;, "-;i '1"1\ \ll,'/ / Ii' (c;; Ie;, <I:;; "II "Ii \1\1',( / ~ li',(" {i,'c,; '\l iI'llIl'''- I)' 1(;' r ICd "\', I! «II'" / II 'I U ,,: '1';, • II II uiJ'J / lei i' :r;; , II 1( (Oj~" /1 f ,r;; '11 · '"tnT / l't''-:''» • 'ill !ilI't /It.' 1\1 I "l> · ~'l n'l,! Ii'\, li q) , l'~ Iff?: J II: lll"iV '1'11 fo';t /010 1 'OJ' 'II' t flIZ: niJJI\\:;'~ 'll OT J iJf:fo~r;; ''II' 'if iltt I {Ji "( \(;,'~ , ~' 'Ir 1111 ~r, / Ii.' ft, ,/ ;,:~ , 1\'\rtC!)'t/f'I\//.,r;; '1'11' fll'~;' ;' II f: / J~; , 'If 1\ n/l ! t 'II ".. ,(;; J I( 'Ii II )1'/: ,/ ";, \1' Iv,q, , II (I ~ '/ / ~: ' ?~ 1 ,~v 'I: Ii fD l / ill; )i -e d'JI , '1\ 'If {ll'{ I h f(ll '0 , lr 1~ I),Y,}' / ,eh Ili,n ~1, Jt'1\' ~Vt I / tlJ,.{;.'~ . "1' l' n l: / \\! ',-: (i'i'~i ; lll;\; ';(' i 1\ l' lei, ,r,; ) 1T ti~7: / 1\ u'~l ,C,' I -U-If {ll t I 'l: l' -II ~ij' d T '[ C\~' /1[ -,f" l ':', , 11 'II liil '~~ j ,( l '\1' ,r\! '~ '~' fli 'J': lip li\\ '(I' "ll 07: / ./ If) If i.\I' , II \ill i: / 'II" {i' '\r ":\, r'l\ If u~,( / Ii' / !l'i,oI;i -"'I\' T ililJ: ,I in)./. !c', <; J'\I \( Ilv'2: J ~) ,~~ t, ,r~' 'y \:irll~" / ,IJ ~J.,(~-;'~ j t If 1\1\ -.;:-/ f: 'J.~ r;, ~c,;"-' \!' Ii' fi::: /'i' f' fli'~ -'V11(J)'( /7(:rH<~i 'lln-:t',/~li,f:;,/,r;; 'll tell',t / .r;;:\1 !<f~ "ll «lIt ,/ i\.~f~ / .i: , l1r 0 i. I ~ i C i. ,[-;;' 'II l!',(j 1. ;' .i ~' { ,i~ j lll' OT I :,l~( / :r,i • 'i,i 'r ~'!I-:t rCi: \! ,:' "" J . if '\1' {},7( / -((~ ~:/ .. ~, 11 J:'I~ '1 T 'l\I:;'~ I' \\1 1; ('f";" , ~- 'II' ,\i<T .'i\~'i/~' ,; , K 'II (ill ( / / 11' ./ ,r;; , 1\ \1 ~ II, / ~ 'II' '(II'~i , II 'II ~il{ / -0 II ,Ill ,r:; " '\I ll,t!I.( .I II! \J 0:;; 'I;; 'I!' 1 Ii 11 ';( ;'\\ r: ,I) d;; , 'il' '\\ 1[\1 'T ! "I '~' 'j; [d /'nl'llfr l,r~i(I;,r~q'~ '11 n7' I .llf~ 'J/ r ; J II nl?: J c.? ~ "!~i ",:, 'II I(~~,": !("U,,~~f~ "[11['):7! I',l\'b'~j'!~ "\\"(.'('iJ;P ,,-fiCI I '-"'; ''i\ 'if n/ ;' ,.; H~;' f; ) 'r -f oJ: I\I/'n 1\J'c,j' 'if '1 d /' ,> (" I)L"a:; J l 'If (\'1 ',[' / ;t CI\J~' 'W lllyr, ) '.: l ~/ 'r;;- "CI\ (,\iT;' iJ l(u'-';: I T 1 (~:( / {j,:: " ,I'; J'II Ti ,~~ T / {j,',t f ,(~ '1f lI' {\I-( J 'iij ";!'i' If',; , \! 'K [\I',r I {il,! . ~~ ,r~ ''i l 0'/ / \\ I!' ,f)I;r:1 , '1\' Ii !!)t, J IV ,(; '(ll ,!~ " Ii 'II' (\\t't)' //IT)',If7, , 'Ii '\IO'{,.l' / r; of;, .t';i or.; , 1\ K ,r\l/ i 11,11' \I.f; "1\\1 1[\1.( / 0\1 II' 'r.J "11,11 II'll,;' It ,ill I\r~, , 11'11 I()I.!' / II, ,I)',r "; , l '\\ 10: ,r ,I i' ",j j': ,r; , \\ 1 {II;( ; r '/ ~'~ iii 'l \1 [lilt / '\)) \\.rlif,'r;'1 'II \\ l('\lf / iOl I(~ -HI '111 (1\lt /{.-.nF ,.~ 'U))'t / ft. 0 II., ,c~ "y'\\ UP l / .I ',I F <,; '''(II' {li',( / r. ',it '(~i , If 1 fv:r / ",; ,:-;; ,~., '1",; '11\ (:I" r ,I ',; II!I ii" 'i~ '1\ l {\Ii. / U1J:r Ilr ;'-,; -, l\' 'Ii' !Cit;-( ; r: HI U ," ~ "11'11 {Ill: r/Il'C,r:i '{llf1,'Z r:(lt,':{r.'Flitd;',(,I /' .t,/",; , 'iI' '\, {Ii or I T "II :( ,(~; , II T fll ~~ f l' 'f)1 t r.i )J i\ 'If {Ii Y /-:\,: if,; ~(: ";i , l\1 -n:.-: / j' \\,,' ( ~~i 'II 'r 'o'( / ~), :r: {il t~ - • ir 'II' ilil ',( /' ~:. T ,1 ~ ,; ~ "'if 'II O:r ! ,I';: II \11 IOU l f(t / -t,i / fil' '1\1 {liT / f'lr~'";i ~" ',( _II' I\~l. .' I ,1-;( If ",i 1 l~C i ';\ ,,': /' .\1' ~ r~< 'u{nZ F«~, lv'f) 1\;----" '(','X ,n,?" /-:(,r,;";~ii.': "il lIC\1 T f l1i, -:: i;i (L' ,. "'(tnT!' / / III \L Iii • '\1 'il o~r / ,(it i1~.' 'll 1(11'1: / it'r:i \\1 'I!'lf 01';: /0 1 ~I Iii 'l 'fo J~ r:j" til ~J);( , ( ,f! ( I ", ~ , ' ) \:\\ I I 1'.1 I()'./V';(', ( ))' I'M 1111,,11,,\\\1,1,\ ! (Ii,/\',VI II ())',I'M 11\ 1,1111'\\\\")'\ Aii\/! \<.\!IUII 1 I \I \/1'.1 /\1\ I:: \ \ (\';"n,' 1((,' ,(In IhUI))IIIIII)I,\ \1 ();" (, n ' T 7 I I (J \" Ji\ I,!', ,) i I . " I I I (I J\I\' N 'v """,' '" ,"" ( ),) "., """ II, HI -I, 11(\1 ' I.! /\ i ) I I I I,ll," , , II II, ,I ' /\ II: I II I I I L' I I: I I II ' 1 I.' 1/\ l' 1\1 ' ,; 1/\1 (II )1\1' )/llldfilll)1 1<.;,)1 ;)1,1) IIJ,I ',;JII.~ Itl/\IJ\! '1.,11"))(1::'-; l'IIII,H:rl ':..~,I lilli' 11.'11111 >1 II/\I.II~III!II(I\I ',1[1\1 'I~ 111'1 I 11I1 r II-'~, ',11/\1 'I.! II 1(11 C) I~II,-,/VI I e!l L~'; I.'I)! IL' I ": 1/\1 '/\ lei 11."'; AI!! IlL":; 1[,\I'I'IIIII!I\III'~,J(lnll\1 'I~,I 'ld'dlllll:'1 I'II!I)III:I'; '111!LeN\ IUlrL'I\1 'II~ , ) 1/ ,I ( 11'.1.1 II I, J I JI ! ( l( I". J I ,1I I I II I J c" J 1 L' .-J I I /\ I J \1 , I ' {VI I II II '/\/\ I II JI I ! 1\ 'I 1/\1 I I I 11.2 12 II I () I I I ,~( I )1 I I I ~:, \I 'I 1/\1 'I I I L' (I I I Ii! I \I ' 11/\1 II 'I I II I ) I I )( Jl 111\ 'I bl 'I~ II) I \I II II I I ~) , , I .. ,.\ ' I ! II I] /VI i J I I 1I11 ) l' hi ' ':; 1/\1 , ~. I , ) I I I ) I \ rr_JI I ;) I I I III I . 'II J II.' ) ( I /\ I ) \I I II' I I I I I ., I I ( 1\ /\1 ' 1\ I J 1:\1 I J I I L: t ' t II' II ' , I 1\ .' I hi ' r' I I L! \ I 'd ' 'I ! /\ 'II, I ' II I II II', 1\1 ';J 'I hi ' 121 L' /VI [! 112 ) L! ~ , 1'111 I, I I ' . .[/,1 'II II..' \1 Ii) I ) I III II t '( I ':, 1/\1 'L! I, 11'1 I t I ) II 112 ( I ' ~ ; hi ' l.! III I L~ II ',~, I'I,I,I')II/'II!I IV\I '1)1111)1e? I '~,; ";1/\1 'Inll(IL",1 IIIIL!', '11,1 '11';,.11.10.1,1 'Ihl '1'1 1111 ') IIIII:!I,I ) 11';!)l!~, 'I\;'.I PilL'

11..'11111,1 111!/\L'[',1 '11·\1 '1-'!'1 12 l.J\1 ",I'U '11i\1 ' II' ,i II II,! I, I '11/\1 ' L'! "J III ) I 11-' I I, 'I I I II I (, 1\.,\1 't 1II1II (; I.; 11,1 I,) I 11-' 1i,1 'Iii'.! , II' I I I 1\ " I I ~ l[ /\ I ' 1\1 'I hi 'III l\ I L' " I ,.I I Jl I ,) II I', 'Iii..! '1-' II I'; II!'.! > I LJ ~ ,) I I I Le (.I 1[;,1 '1/ I) I II'; ',I '!AI 11;\1' I 1I11 II' ;' 1\1 {I 'III I 'I Ii Jl 11-"; '\[' 1\1 ': 1[/,1 ' ! I I 112 ( I! I L It' I I I I I ,I t 1< I Il' ~, '111\1 'I I Il' II 1-' I I', I 1\ 11-' I I \/ I t" I I I I : 'II I !' , ,I t-' I I II I> I I" I II I '~; , I i/\1 ':,I,IIItJIIII<;11 ,)111 10, ~,'l\l-')II/\I)\I 'II'IIIII"II!IIII'; 11/\11)111.' 1111'; 11)1 11 \1 'Ihl ':I,dllll/V\IF', ;\1:>11':;)1(>-1 11 .. ,1 ' I II I'; III.! 'III \I ',11/\1 I 11 ! /VI ,)1 I.! II) /\ I I \I 'I' ; , k'llll I /VII.!'; , \ I ' \ I 11/\1 : pi ,)'".:1,1, I " l1"II'IOld': /7.£il=J'D lllll.llli~ 'fi(fJli T7-zfi~f-il.:rif(jj'tTr7t~:16i'l) , IIll()I~( / U):t:((~"q, ' rJr '1\: O',?' / tfi if (i~ej'- -'If.'~' 1C1J~f.: rl tl(-~~.l! "-'inOl-;([ff("~"-" lCn'lI',?: / !Gi~~;g; '1111111;( / :O:loi d'~~I)l' "'it If. iOl t -; 1.0 ill, ~f -TY (tj) T / '!5 {)I ~l,"!i -, 'l(tOl7.J ~~'Irfll';g '-"·nr irj)'l7 ~;:-f»6~ll '1111 l(rt / tllllIG,'!J1 'i it li))-i T~[(flHfi.~l;' "1 t I{il'?' / l1' (t,f.'D -" '1 ir (ditI~§fi~?9>-·tl-Q]?J)~f'g~j '11 (f)Lt / ff'»Zfl~ry , • 'j(if{))i ll!tli'il?f 'l[ t Ifl):t / r,;·~r:fk~·--' l(i!" iiilz} ii-=;,fi7f.t---'Y'lf ij:;':,7iff:7DZ~) ')1' lr iOll: I Jr illJ£ 'I]) '1 lr ([lIz'nlh~rf~)J - 'tiE Uli7 ! til Y:l)1' 'In(iijY16gl-:0J-~'---'1C-{<<lli7i'f9'!:l1~1J 'Jr lr ([lIZ / /. ~f)I~j)~' - 'Yif ([lit jil>a;if ~~' 'Tt uyt / tfuf::l('i;;- 'int oJ: If£zl( ~-- '-if If.'[§t7/ltTi~ 'THCn.r / "air. ~,';' ''If lr hi t.I\Cil~~ -, I in lUI?: / if~iiI,o-;s;-'-'-J l.lrO-Z16'g«:iI~--rifif«'fi;'TrOIQ) ~; '1 ir ([liZ / (())I/l,ir;, III 'lfY~iJl: 1~{fJ;:n il;- ")i 11' ,nj'i /d~ ~v a;''-'· t 1 inj;( Fl, n;fH~'---"lrY ~l;;r n!i;:cn-;; "'J[' T fll?: / II.rlllJ'il> 'Y"IOd':: 1[:1 Hl;' "l'(OZ izir n/ft./ - "I t ICJit. /ltt"lIlll;-J'nr ili)-z}I(;'((~'iJ;.'n/ /I t 110) T /":rJ In) pj' iii " 'l((t»;t / 'l t» Iii II ~.-- ;, tl(O 7. / 0 Tn! ]; it ,:' -"-',~ 10;?~ I ~~ In) kllt7 -, '1 it 67 } [ll,oF Il" 'l 'Ir i());t / t 1i1l1!l il;' "if 1 oi~(l«illO) U/IJI 'J): l(!oi:t ! tfi,([~:L~ ~;'-4rt oz71flS£ i!.7-"rifltft,7-[IGc if, ''[I" t ([l\';r-: /91(';,~>1!;: "it ;fii.1lZTi!;;G-[~I[1- , '1(1 o;r}TC'fiiEn;,·---rit-r027Z tfr,'El\7-'-·lTiEf.t7iniiC'~) 'II OJ" / q~,HE /IJ" "-lfT~lii'IHi1~~1; -, -(lc 1O« I i:{f:ET:- 'llCrtliiITl tl!J··'n'irlt}t7~lEfJ 'lll[\I;r / IIll:[ II;' "" tlr in?: l t,[ it F -'. 'jE 1 in z / Z:L t.n; - "'I'll" '~tt / t--:-tt::iv -'lCj(iiit 7 tt])Zt~/ '11 ([]I;?:: / {ii'it III "" If'tt{>>iIh1{F' 't ir i{ytIl'!:ft: le;'- 'ir.fiOit J§~-tli7-'-'ir 'ffJiz'n~;-<i:f:[ II~ 'Jr 1 (OJ i /' "':'.tli (:'10-" --"Y"[( tlllZ Tr: il}i :t:]i -'J 1-lln);r 1 ~(~d~: 1[' --, f'l(ifljY / f;,I}-:E'n,. '-'-;ft.1f117.1it»'~ [: iI. '1 'If <o)'i: / «'~I't.it IT?" . 'liOn'. /fftf;;t:"rr; '"-fir 07 /(()~-t It:;' "'ifYilYi: /F§:c i0:-'-"Il;l(6:tT:(:~~:c ~,' "lr 1 (('111' / o<r;;t'fi;, "lCflrft ref:, Il/:n; - -riCrtflJil ~:tl ~;it [,'- 'iff (f1it"/lIi-fi."L u.:--'-'(tlfli7.7T"n;'tr l<-iJjt?shwill' IZoo, [\/11'. Vikl"lll /\~JLJilIW(rI illl{l IVII. ~,11'llill IVlullclnllll(JI.-I, /\1 IVI)(,-rI E":'; rill 111e' 1·I~SI-'IIIHh·~liI/I.·)cllli 1)ldil·:(~. C: 01 1/ r. II; "\III nll(jlll\!I·lItl'-.II~ 1~11I~::;; .. .J)IIJJSIf IICI[ 1II1I1Ii1~lfjl~ II{OlilltJl J. \/\/1 If': 1.\1 C I FZ C I) U I L C' I '.'; I) r I. ( ) I . ,)1 I.l '-Ii 11'1 " I) I i I )' 1)(' illluWCLI I:u 5C(~ 1111' JIJ(I~")J1](:'111 ',' J. WII (' [11 (: I Lli ~ j U I I q 11'1 r:: I It" 11"1 tI, I I,,: I·('I~IIII le( I in 111(' I li(j(:!,1 ;> . \( .- ,(~,) J c.Olnlllllll. hll Lhc c;,~lkp 1.1," ulllvellir'lll-f', r,-II I:; (Ir \N,I)(C,) 111/1 :j.}(11 I ,III' de,i1 willi II J(~ I f:?~-'I )01. I ivr' ,II ()llil ]('111:, ;111111 r~:,',r'll Ill' II J(~ ICillll(:11 1.1.11111';1 'I', I til Llif,: II eli I i 0 I I C I 5/ \! e 11111 I I (, ,I I II I I II f' 1(::;1 IIII i( 1(-:111/1\11.')1\11(, il "1'1r-~,-1111 1"'(1111"11 «(11111',('11'(11 ,II" iIIlIJii(IIII:, ,JIIII 1)('111',1'11 II)e I ('( 1)1 (I. /.f".'{(O) /r F .-;r.7/.1,"P' 1'~ 'P)':;/I//(P.II [i, I "'iJrp1'{1'('{ (fl,nrf l 'l:: I II' ", , I. L (;ilJc~~ jllllUnlr.lll ul 111i', CUIII'I 111'15 5U ["ii' IluL IlC!.~11 illlplclllClll:Cll, ill,J~,11111(JI ,'IS <lj)111(IIII-icdc 1(~CJi(;I(ll.il)11 11;1'" nul: LlCI'~n Cl'ltlclccl 1))1 IIIf' I ()lllpelelJi' lec,li:-;l(ll\llc~, \fill' clil-eel lile IJllll:ies II) 111,liril'ililJ lilc ~,Ll'ILu:; (11.11,1 ;'\"; il I', () I) tu i II i II Y I I J I lily, " \NOS r:;llllllli',,;i(III Id I I )( : ('IS (:2:aYUn :HJl sec ;' iI!'J, ~;II;III (llllilJllr:' III Il'lllil!1I ill lJllCI'IIi(III, illllll/lilJ(! U'le (]clJuclicllLory IIICcll,ilJislll IlIll\lillr'rl rUI' 11)1 [:II\:' 1\11 )1\l1(~ ill [III' ",1 III:IIII~ ~~;::I i cI 1/ () C U 1.11 I I (.11'\ IH) II I I Ie! ( 'I I Ie ri II 1'1 I \ II I h Y (() III i III I ill() [li I ( ! I j I " ; II (' I III ' C1r(Jlc~;iJi(1 j\.lCI~jlll(~I1L, ITSI)(lrILicllljl\I[Jf"IC \N,ilkr'llllli::; «(jllli 1111UII(jll r;(IIIIE' 111()llliIH'111 rll'l i',ilill', Iii • ys.. NDI:~l::[S\,QI>, 18IJIlIl(,~1.1 (lr~ ~ 1I~·p'IJlU):2' SC'I.' IJ.'J, lllc' illlclilil (11(1('1 ,1;iI(~(1 ClJ.CU lllC)hl}(lS~,c\1 II)' 11'1(, :;I'I.lIF'lllr C(IIIIL ill ~HLIIII .. ((I:.:) 1\ ((il'!,I1'.i.)lj 11'1.11:,'1:1 (' I il i I I c cI ~1-Lcll}jLXJ LJ .LljJ. Li_ &, U I~ s" , \'~;;'; ,Jj CU, I Ill.' ri I I ,Ii j I II I ( ) I I 1(' I II i I I I I I ( : ( i'I';r' "I ;..;, \,J LI LJ!L J\lLc;I~LillL.l~ ld.lJJ. iJ....l I c: I,ll) I l (c cl il ,; (.,1'« 'H[J' '']1) 11 S(: C ~i; 'IJI}' ,II I{ I 1;1' ,I I V, I III ' jUll~IIIIC),lt cll'1tE~cl o.'J.J.U.i(lHl 1'leIS';I',1 ill III(', ,:l,q' cd' G~JiJILi(J IZ~.l111 (:)l.Il.1ld). '':';. Lt'ulllcci CUllll~>cl 1")1 UIC IrSI"'llJlc'llljl'.lllf"'IC \lI,'II(-~III(::'i'IIIV (11111(1';('(11111' prCI)lc r ur I:he. IJel.il:iollE::rc.;/IICI1CloI5 illl l./I'i1111. (.,r illl(~I'illl (11(lr'I:; 1(';,lliIiIIiII(1 tli C I' e 51 1 (Jll cl e I 11./ 1\1\'11\11 c: 1'1 (J I 1'1 r ( ~ I I 11. I \i i I II) III !:' I I I r I( 'Ill I II (' c.; i If:: c'; '" I I 'I Ii I "I I I Y l:IIP.III lill Ihe P.II<1I.IIJICII\. (d ,'III ClI'I'lllllli,ll,:' l"lJi:~"'lIi(III, ill le'IIII', (Ii IIii' SlllHCllle Celliit ill Ilul',I'; /I() ;111(1 /11 I'" 11110: jll(I~IIIICIII' ill 111(': (,~I';C' Id .' 'lll.i')11 .~~ill~JIJ C$lIl=lI';::I), Wlli(11 IJcilll willI IIIf' illlll'II:i'lill\(~ ('vi( Ii(lll III' 1111,-lllllllllii('11 ~"I.II)lCIII(, CUlIll: 11,1(1 l.iiIC!(\.I;(1 l'l'IIIiI\f,i1 (Ir 1111,llllllu'izCII '.Ilililllcl:,/II,wvl',!I" \1\1 i L'll U I II. ,wv ;:Ii I.i 11 ~J r i 1'1 ill iJ II ( din r: I J\ I if ',i k " I I I I I (: ,'I III " I (' I I I (I (' I i ( ) i I "(' I I, I i I J J, II I I ' ; <':11. LlIE:' 1,1 (,((,r:" 1'("IIIIJi'lIl"IIII('11 11)1 Illf" IllrlICj,-) (.f)11JI1JiII'e(! III <.II'}lp",I!'(1 11)1 l.h e 1\11) IVI ( .. I. /\SJilill, III IIle illl('lilll 111,1"1 11,111'11 (J 1ll.l/()(I(, 1)~I';:,(!tl ill ~.,ulIiJiI lI(J,ll.lJ1J.'.s"CbJ::i.c;, (~UIJll..l), 111\: I'IIII"willll ," 1';1 'I \/;-11 illlJ IJIll( Ie II'l 111(' ',J II 11 ('1111' .1.11.11 L VII,I"; IlilJIJiiqlllf'ci 1)\1 111(' (111111',(,1 rl'll 1111' 11:"II!Jllrit:!III/I\1I1\1I11 "\/\/Ililc we tlllllcililke Illi e , (~)'('~ITi'",c, wr:'. 1,lil'c~(1 1111" /\utllOI'il:ics til ';r;c tu il 111,11. I.llU:~8 jJr-'I:~UII:';, willi ,III' cLllryill~J UII 11;l\l\Ikill~'1 01 livilir'<=; (Ii ,,/lfllll iln' S(IIFlllill~J Ilil I') U 1.1 lie I cl I'l (I w i I II() III il I I V ,J t I I 110 I i 1)1, C' 1/ r-: I I i I I ~ I C U .. l I I I ; I I I I I' wiUI

1.110: l'rl'c.;C~'llt 11(1)1 ',IIII,'IIIC' ill [(IIIJ", ;:11(' ICIII(II/I'II rl)I'I.i'Jwil.h. 111i', illf'llllll"~ 1111:-1111'11()lilE'cl Ililw\(illtl, sCJuCllLiII~J (lll llili ili( ',111'1'1 ", rUI" 11;:11.115 ,1111 I I 11I1.llil· Ilill k '" illclu(lirl~1 iJIClY~JI(lIIIILi. \!\Ir Ililc(J 1111:: J'.leilli /\lllllillisl.l,ili(111 Lu Lilkc sLCII,S ill 11 nl-,(Iiill ('1)1 irl [' (Jlli-Ji,)( II ,ILiI)11 willi IVll:l) ill II I I\IOJVIC wil.h 11('~Cf:~,Sill'V i'l',~,i';lillll-0. rlCH11 1,Ieilii l'lllil!' III clciJl' the IUurl:;, :;lrl'I'~I:" Ililill),ill'is, Ill-lllc~ ('1(, IIV LlI'I,] 1I1 II U I'i z Ct I I I r:r 1I11il n \. :~/ I, I II 1;'111 (' I ';'/ h i'l W h: I :;. " " . ) _I, \\2.U. -111(' 1\lc'N I)plili I'Jlllni(~ipf-ll ("-Ullllllil-Ir:'c Ilil~" rilr,f) sulllllilLctl il:,; ~;ll)(:111('. \fl/I' 11,1\11,: Illl'l.:,il.lclclllll(~ :'(1)1'1111' 5 u I) I I I i I IT I I lie r I ) I (. I I ", . I I I ( ~ ill F': (I IIV II i I II r t:J II,:; I II I ( I ( J I 1\11) 1\/1 (

(11)(;5 IICI\. ('IP"lc' IIIII\I\C'III', :,11111 "~; LIII)C;I" ill Lilt: ;11(:{I', uIICI('1 ""ICU. Ilowc'I/PI, ill II If' ,'"Iii I :.,(:J-ir'lllC I (~rr.1 (':11('(: IliI', IJ 1': e II III (l( I c I I I I II ~ I ',1111', W II I ) I I U I I U I II il V (' I I (' I I I Ii', I, i I II I

(11)(Jt~1 :;;Cf'l,iUII //~', III licf:III(' 1111I1e:1 ,c;Cr lioll .Till of 111(' 1\I[iJVIC /\cl, 1')1)'1 Ilul Willi CII'(: tlllilIIIIIUlisccll)lI,(Jlllillllilll.l lo ('iliIY (Ill Illl'7.iIICS.-:-; (')'; 1I,-lwi<C:I'c;/c;ITec2i: \/(:II(llll ~;. 'III('V lJil\lP 1.)[:'1:'11 rir",( lil)(~11 ,1.', 11111<,(' V\lI\(1 (11 C "I(JII~I Dietl" ill 1.11(': 1\1 [) IVI I,. ill(-'~J, II\Ir·' I,-Iii 1(1 1/11I1c~1:;II-III(11N11Y ,I/IY I)C:/,';(III \1\11111 \/iolt'll.es Ill(' l(ll/lf :;lllllll( I I If; I (./CI i}l ('\1. Ulllr:I' {I H~V ';1)( 111111 IJ I:; C U /lip (' II r: cll.l) \ 1\, l r:: V I II C' I i I I"i (I I Lli (! I,-lIN I I I 21)1 1)(-" ·c; II i I ,lIi1 V iJlrJCllt:!Pr.!, if iL i:; rClIlIICI I II 1~I"E;"ll .. : UIICIII(~ 11~)I\I:~11i11 '1111' I'llobk:III~; I'll:rtl LII Ilf" ,IIIIIIC'<;cIIIIV IIIE' 11'~li",I'lll.Il(' (II IIII' I-Ulelll(lkil)(J ;.lllllltJl'iLV \fII(~, !.III'lcrl:llc, IlIISCI\I(: 111;-,1 ir il is rell_ Illlll: lllf; 11I"1~,1111'; \1\11111 r(-J!I ill 1.11i:-< c.--ilc:\.J(JIV IC:CJllill: 51 1PI-:icil 1111)I.CI.l.illll, lllr' /\11 Illll)' 110. C,[lilillJly ,1111(:/111011 III C I I \I C I LI lei I I il:, r ' ; I I I ( , I "f"

1.I11' I I I I I I diET ( J[ :~ tic II i II ( : I I ; 11 ::; I I U ill, L ()J '; I I I;,)' i I II I P. i1 <c; f ~ r I (111 I I i I i'I (' Il I I.i I I If: . 2~J. Tllel c 11,-1<; 1)(;CIl Ill) ',,('1 jrlll:; I,lll,jl'~cljllil lu Illf' ',of 11(~IIII' SLltrlniU,f~d e)y I\lUI"'i(: \/IIlliell i.'.; ;-) I IIIIIIHCIICII~"ivp '·;IIII.'IIIt:. C('I-tClill clircIJioll5 11111/(', IICl\lVc:V('I, 118811 :-;UUClhl' ('1)1' 1'11)111 III i:; C () U It. I!II e, <I i> I) I I I V C' 1 h (~ :,( II (~II Ie'; III) III i II r(1 II V 1\1 D IVI c: ' ]0, U' is 511LJlllillcI.I 1)(~rllIC Lie, Iini. [lie ~;(llcJrlP"; wllil.11 II u V [' " C (' Il <I il )J r () 1/ P. ( I I) )I I II is (I Jl II I' II III:; I. I. ) C :; III.) j C~ 1.1 1 I ) ill 1)1 1-\ cI 0 I' I I "(' S III <I I I I 1(1)1 I) (: r I ;-) Ii If ~ (I i Il C (J n ~:, () I 1,111 I I: \1\1 i I II tll~: 1\lilUCJlliJl l'olii:Y Oil Ullli'lil Sllcel: \lcncl(II::),

111.1 1](::, wilhuul SlJ\/illC) 111,11. W(~ 11<1\1e ,JIII'I{)V(.~(1 l.h(~ ~)l.lll~IIIC'; ,l', rl'LlInf'Li bv I"I(~D ""11 I\IUI"I<, I rille; ir':Lli:';I<1UII C illl.r~I'vr'I}(~', iJllcl rl',-111I8:; ;)IIIJIllF'1 ~,III('~IIII:~ ,'1/ IC'~II.II'lljUI'I:; ~JII\llClllilllJ c; I I dl ~~ I 'II r; II Ie,; , I 11 <:11 111/ i " I f" I I (J i III )I S L11 ) CIS (-' I 1(:' 1 111 ' :; ( 11 C II I (' :; 111 C' Illll (' I I I -' )I I'll I . [ ) ,'11\1 I 1\1 I ) IVI C, II i :.; w (Cd I :' (' II II: ( I ilIDI: (111)1 illllllilli:,,11 (ll.iV(' ,II I i(J11 ir; ,-IIwlI\".', :,1 "')jl~('1 . I I) li)\IV l. h eli: II I <1)1 iJ c r I III I II 'r I I))f I. lie,: 1 U 11 Ij )(: I (' II L I I :: ~.J is I ;-1 Il" I ~ , y;, ~';1I1:1jed l.C1 11110' ,illIll,e,(li(1 III {)(liriG1LiulI,',jt.i I 1'1 1I1j1."; ill

1.11 C ~; ( II e rile:; ;, u I.) 11 I i II (' I I 1:1 \f IVII J) 011 I I 1\1 D IVI C:, LI J(~ ';," I J(' (,lie ,lllill'overl, :IH' '-.;Iill ;l!lllllIliliF~S ~·;III'l" 1111\/\/ 1,11--1' ;:l/lIJnJI,Jli;-)I:C <,18['1:; III iIlIjJir:'IIICI11' lilo ~;( IICllle rllllllllllilil. 'Ill cLise or (111)1 rlirriuill y r,II'PII 11)1 lilf'lIl ill illlj dCI rlClll il 1f,1 1110 51,llf'I11(,';, LlIf:')I e:,II,1I111,I\I('~ III(~ lil](~II)I [II <11)1'11)1 I(J Illi', CUUI-[" iJ, L'I~:;II)(, ill lll(~ ICc(~111. .illrlllllll'I" ill Liw 'i-I',I' I)r 0~lil,llILll(,JIII (:"l.II.lI"), - ... ----+---_ --_-0_-_ " 7 j. L 11 j.ll~1I (J ~J I ,II ) il I;' uri 11 C (,1 rn cI ,1\!i I: i I. II II ~~ I) C f~ I 1 ~', I iii (' I I

1.1) II L I 1"1 E'I C c, II ill I I. w ,Ill 1\ 1111 cil ill E' 1\ I Il.IlI" I i I.)! wll i ( : 11 c; 11 ill I llLl.CllI.I (() tilC I cdl'(?5,sc:1I "r ~II i('VilllCCS (JI" ::;(111,111.<:1"'1 Illlwkel::;1 l"l(ICI"-1 le:;i(I(,lll.~; 1"11' illl)! utiler 1)f'~I~:,1111 11)1 h (' ,J I i I III ell l I ) C' ill ~.; (I Lj(Ji n " I III c:: I I (~l.. is i 0 I 1 () r 1.I1 c: \I (~I II I i I I I I C U 1111 I 1 i U c c: ( 1"1 ,-Ii I 1 ) I ) ,II i'llli ;-1 I) 11 I) () I' 1.I1 ,11_ CI r r i 1.1 il \I i L i ~) e, I ~ I UllL LJl'lu\I\I:- rhere ::;llilll I.!e ,Ill /\1 )1')('11,:11 c 1-\lILi I()I il.)/. ()I 1 II \(~ rLlI\fl/'llllill~J Ur I lei il.;CJll~~ l'ecei\l8ll 11)f II j(' C II il i I 1")(' I ,; ( l I II I Iii s /\ u l.Ilf JI i I Y :,; II illl ,Ii I r" I I I I I I l 1"C(lrc",;;-!I ur Cllicv'·lllI:(::' Ill" :jllll'il.l(-:~I~;1 IItIVllkl~I:,) LrilclE'I'~;1 11~'~,ill~'lli r; (II

(III)! ()Lhf~1 1)(,'1 <;1 II I. '111(' 1-\1 "llnl-il.)! :;lluli ,lle,l) Ile,-11 JI IIJCDI:; il~Flill'·;1 II j(: (Ie,isiull ur \/(:IIClilll.J I ("lInlilill.C'f: (IVlllill). /")1'1 i',illil', ( I r I I Ji r;' 1\ I 11111 1I i 1)1 I II II (" ,~; 1.11 iJ II (' I 1 ( JP d II f' r U I C ,I I I i ~.J III 'I I~OIIIl-n (ll ill illl)l l.I)I"'IIJr::1clli «(Illil l ~;II,III 1)(: !"ill,". Illi:; I\llllloril.y r;11<111 1)(' il-liUillly Ile,-IIII~(1 I)y ,-I 11(!1~;llll iJIII)uild(~r.I II)' 111(: (~llilil-l-'f:OI-SI)11 Il;:1\1illl.") ('Ii Ip,lc,11 (I )lOClrs 11·'~Jc!l (II .ill(/il i,'11 l:>iJ("k~JI-I)IIIj(I. rllel C' 1<:111 1)(' mOIP Illilll ()n£" 1"ll(~I'I"I'='I' ill Illis 1\llllllllil.)!." " ? t!. II I 1 lit" " ,:1 i cl ,1J"f i (I (1 \. ill VII Iii i.l1 VII ll:, il n-i I IIIC' I I 1)( ~ I"f) I I"

1.I1i~" CUI III (III )IILlI /\111)11',11 ?CJ l () il Ilil~' LlC(~11 ,;1 ill (·~II liidl 1\/1) IVII ~ ~,Il llil (C III IJ " )I \I\f jIll I II C' I ) I I I r; 1<:; VII II i d 1 V\I I II " I I I II ' l~l(lsS('IIIJ)f till-: "(I./llllil~dl'l,/ IflCI.ll("lnisJI"l u.ll·ll('IIII>i'-lll'(1 ill Lhe SII-1('III(' (111(1 wili( 11 h(l', Llcr'll 'II)IJI(I\I(~II 1»)1 IIli', ( 111111 rOI the I\IDI\/IC ,11'(:;1 1 11111(",', ~,lTII CIIII':"I,':; dlC" 111,lllr' ';I"ljCI I IT1al:L(:I-Ur (.11I1IIcI1C)(, Llcrlllr:~ (:1 11i(IIIPI-IUI'IIIII (JI' ill <111)1 uillcl' CIJlrJJl('If'111 (-IIIII\.. ]'; . II I \I i e VII ( I r ~,I I ( I I :' (. i i .' I I 11:; ,:; , l. h fO: I) il \IV k (~, I ~.~, >:.; '-I" ,-Ii I I ~ I " ill If I \I E: I I ( I (I I (, I 1"1 I I '~ I Cli I i I I f.' h\,I I H:: L ) i:~ I'Jl "C~ I Zr-' ( II (~,',:; I II .s l II C II len IC I Ii i ( ) I I eli ill I ( l \/(c~ . I ·11 t' I (" '; I )( ) ultl I I (J l. I I C

(111)1 direcl ''1)Il) (),I('II Lo I Iii'; (llllll: 11)1 \IV'I)! (Jr r·le::.11 1)(-~lilil)1I III 1/\::;, I )VII(I"c,il1(.1 II If: I li"1 IIllf' IJ.el II C'.;r,(ll 1\lICIII,-llli',111 III U \I i rI C 1.1 i I I I II (~ " I .1 I C' I I J(-' . I CJ_ II 7G_ l-hl\l\lE.:V(~I, IJ(-,rlll (~ ]()II' Jtlllr:~, )(l L I, LilC '-IIII.JlllIJI i.ill' Guvel-lllllr:nt i::, Lu 1=:11;11:1,11,:11/\/ Oil Llle Ila::;is ur III(~ I',ill rnRI1Lioileci iJl)uvp. (11- ('II IIIC h,I:,i'~ uf ,JI"ly ,11111::I)(IIII('liI Lli C IT (J r S lJ I i 1 (11-Lli ~ II ;:-1 w k (' I ::, II I,-I)f III C' C i ,; r: I y I, II () W I I If' C(JIltUUIS cd: LlICil l-i'Jllls" was (J I I P81:iLiullt::rs/vcn(lor:; I II I ne,1I1 111111 1111' Ullhil)(Jer~Li 01: (111)' Illdec' or 11}(~il ,_llllil (~ ill IIH:' 1\11 llVl1 _ jllri:,I_lil lillll, ill '-"1 1\IUr,IIC_ -:ui.lIL_ ~~I,,:' rlil-Illel sllillJlill('(\ 111,1i- ,-I','-,llllliIILj, willl()lli ,111111illilll_j, 111')1 IIIl' L ~~ . U I, ) II I III illl)' {Iili(' 1111~~I('rlf\.r;I, . ( r~, ) l' IE' ) II (' ( I I l/ I. /I r , l/ , (~{ I II '/II ) I "II ljvl{ I rri(l(wil.ll;:li(.~LI(II.()\CI,.,'()III··1 1111 I' (. \ • Lhe Followillg lTiteri;) rlIIIJrII\/f'ci/;-]cll'lill'cl hV IIH" \/r'llIlilllJ (:rJllllllillr'I' III shorl:li.sL Llle eligil.Jle ;-]ppliC(lIlI:=; i::; ~;C'l rllll:- "1'\, Tllul L1le rJiIJ"li,1 cll,lllifIVI'II/,'If.I(llllpl.l I.lY III(~ \/('IHlillfJ C U 1111 II ilL eel (l :" IlU I I I i ~, I I 11(;~ (: Ii ~; i I J I r; I~I I II" i c ,m I ~, i' ; i', ' , UI 1(181-:- ( i) T II C " ill J! ii" I I I ,; ,; I H ) 1111 I I II:: I I' <, i c k' I I I I ) r I) r~ II Ii \1\1 i I II II i ' : 1"<JII'lf~ 1'('r;Ji:~l(,1 el.i ill (:If'l II1I III 11,)1': ;Yi JJC'1 ;ill',;11 i:1I1 f<l piloL(J [,IZoll UI I,I~Z() I f'll ilil i'd Ie'. ( i i) T II e "Ii J I," ii' 0 II t '~I}( 1 I III I l)f' i'l "I ,-I i () I, \I i 7, \I\f i I I I r) \I <" I I: ~ YC(lI-S ur t.IQ0 ,IS Ilel- '!,llill llilill n~lliric,ile IJI illll' u'II'ifjr'Llif' (II' ~;CII()1 iI (r!I'1 iril, ,11 e ['II

(iii) Ille 'll,!diGIl" <,llIJlllrl IH! ~I Ilf!l'lly ,-I', 11('1 illlllll'" reCOlrls ur 11(' (IZ['VCIIIII') I,ll ;:1', VIIIII(cl,liJilil)l i('IUIII', III C()V(=:If'lllIClli' Ilf 1\11. I ril'I)I'lIli C"lCIIlI<ljik ~:,lIvi(lIlil .';'IIICI<IIII: \I u III E.! I a I:" (~ ;:J' I cI I I III' ; I VI III I r,' I ,11 " f' 1< I\y ~J U 1)1 ) , (i\/) fllc~ ;::1111:Ilic,lId c..llflillil 1)(' I f'I,li';l01C!II <l(; IIC!I 1\lIli"I( :':')1 I-eel \lelllllll-'; :';, 111'.'1111' II If' i'()lil.)I \/('Iiril.<:d if III I II III,' ;.'llljJlil ;JIII ~,IIUI riLl 1)(· ,:~\I,IiI()1 "P, (\I) '111(' ,11'IJiiccllll, III Iii;; Ilr:IICllIlnlti. f'llilily 111('llrlll'l C:' 111) u "-I I 101.

1.1 C (' I I II "( I V (' II (I I s II (J I "I I II () I 1,,1 \I r. ,II I)' I" III 'I Ich\:Jfl7<:lli/\I('llllill!l fll- ,111V ():Ilr'1 11IIc,ilw:.'<; IlIfe'IIIi:,I'" ill

i)clili 1.1:,; IWI'ICtIJIII \lelilil ,'II'if,11l (II 1\11 I 1'//(/1\'1 C'l) , •

(vi) j"'I'crel('III.T' will L'r Ilil/r'll II) (1lIrdiC:']llI~,; wlH) j'lll: I) h \f sic: ;::111 y Ilill I tI i G1IJ I:) r: I I r I I 1/\/ i \ I r ) w:; 0 I S e r li r ) I' r j I' i l. (q 1(, iJ LI {J \I C (, () )I r: <:1 I::; , C1 I" I· ,-,', I I I r I iii I 1 I i ~ 1 <'1 I" 5 ( I r ,I ; C t; I ( ('IE' C e 5 S (J I-Y eel Li ri r : iJ L p 1 iJ I,W S 1 IIJ I I Ii 1.1 el'l ill'l cI I 01,1 )(;-:11 i I JI I n 1<':1 y I) e ~] i v (' I I i I I I h F' () III ) \/(' II i ,: eli il ) " Tile cdlirliJ\lil I I eil.!'ll CiI,()U,21111 1 II I ~ 1(1-'1 il'l IllIllll.JCI', 'J lie 1'1(11111)'-'1 of ilill Jlicclili s, wlw Llle 1'0:;1 1(jllllclll /1\11 JIIII( ;' • I. - Veil( Iii HJ ~; I 11.1 I Jlllillill Cf' ( ~ ) i I.e liP (II-If-e r -) ,1 l ~ ...... ' -) \/C;lltJiIILJ (.; til) _ll I I I I I I i II C; ~ ( I I CeJi II ill Jr. I I 1)19 i C I I f~ ) ,II I( I /- . -' VCIJ(.Iin~J ::; II II IJlllllJillcf' ( I Ilrfll ( ('111('111 )_ -' - lhe 1-(~~;IJOllCJc~I)I:/I\IUIVIC rlJI-If,'ljlil,Jiill'I \/(,'nililill ;Kii\lilil'~; ill iL,; .i11Ii',rlirliIJII I, cOlllillue un all '(le; is vvllcl(' is' IJ(l~;ic;f (ll"lrl :~uc:11 s(a(ll', 1/1/1 1 i', III III'~ '.

1.U. IJ.D, ~'I(lVVIIIIC)lf , ' ,)1, II II' IIII' S 1I jll 10' II I r:' C e)l I r I: I I ill I I I i I (' I I (' I I \.II il I II I (' il:) I " I) I J Ii;" E" l,) (J \I ( ! I I II I I I' I I I I I \I I' ,I I' I I, I I ,I IJ I ( ) v ill E:' (I r U I' i I" I Llll? ~; l'll (' III r: II 1(' 111 i I J I II '( I ill IIII' ,-' 1\11 r: ~ ii i (I i I II ielll I(' I II I I 111/1 I j' • url! t'111(.'II, IE'CiI-IIf:ll .'_,f'lli"1 /\,1111'(;-11,' liT III' l'r~lil-il)llr.'lr, ',IIIIIIIiII"11 11],,1 lJ';PdJof~ K .~j. 11,-,1 /,'1. ··_· .. t . 1\1 0 1\11 C ,II E' iJ Ll c:; ron n I I I ,Ii:c' I I i r I I I If ' )II ~ ,~II <' U I ) ( , , IN II i ell \1\1 i1 ' , I III i I I I i Ii I' I V . II ,I cI ~) /I IE-: nl, Ll e C If; r:: U I' U I tI P I (I r u I I \1 I I il "I, ill J F~:-; I ) e r.J (J rei J( I I ) ,II III I IC ~ I II I II 111\ I r, , i I. II\! ,1" (,(" II II i 1.1 I" Li ( 'I) h (' II ill rId I III ' • (-clilil)}lr;IC;/\!('IICIOI'~ Illill 11)(')/ VlfC'II' ('lllillell 1.1) ~}If)III: III illlf"lilll 111111"1 lil)11 2 J. With lef"cl'PIICC I.u 111(,' ('I)(:'Ci,=11 Pllllli::,iuIIS /\cl, 1(~f)IIICII')I'11i111 ('O'Ii:C)(1. f):; I:II(~ UI1(~ ill wilil 111111' 11111,1.',1' "('III I(),II·IIIII"" .. I)I" I I I I' I ' ,1,1 c; . 1 (' r: I I I (' "I I '( , R"ii{!<F' r.(. (I( ./.11 I I' I r 11-"',"II~IIII"-11 II'.-,'? "" I:(,"I'II'C,(:",-.II 1.1,';(,' Ill' ,111\1 11111('1 perrrlClllell: S(I-ll(: ,I.II (~ _ ,- 'C"._ _ _ ) 5cllelrJc IlilCI 1(lj).~,0.(J ,lllel LlIPI r::fDI(', 111E; (II "V illl CIIJICI:CII.iull 111.11 1,111 11(' • dlill III(' pl'O\l;~:,iUIIS uf LI)(~ ':;j.lr~I,;'11 I)I(I\/i~;ilill', /\11' 1(1 'oIlhlllil 11',iI (:\1(:11 111(~ .';I'IIII'IIH' COllrl' hut.! recCl~Jlliz(xl the r'lll 1ll,Il LllC ~;llr( illl r'l()vi:;illll'; /\1 Ii', 1111' IllilV Ce.lll:J,iI I,IIN go\/elllirl~J 111(' 1i1:~ltI illll.1 il \<\11)1.11(1 Il,:I\I(~ Illill,,'I)lI)VI'1 IJiIII'1 ) I. ell Lll e:; a n (I (I ( II I I i II i::, II (II i \! f:~ () I ( I (' I r, f 1.11 e 1\1 [) IVI C /'\ ll. r, III /I I (J I LJC i I I \I I) k I '( I II Y I II P I f ~', I I U I I ( ic"! 111/1\1 J.) 1"1< . ,I ~; I III' '" Ii I I \cl" is rlut iii COfiSUlliJIIU: willI /\11;( 1(' '11., Ilr I:I)(~ Conslillll;()" III IIIIIi" ,/1111 call 1,("; 11iJ.:;.seci.

¶211'/11. I I i I) <'I Lli i, /\11 ViiI ,I[ f"~ rUI ~-, I ) I I 1 ( ~ :1 If(' /\uLlluliIV" cUIIsliLuLpcl un( 1('1 II Ie (li:'1 illll' I C( Ile~;:',,~li Illr:~c:ll(llli:;( II II II 111(' CiJS(~, wlKTPin Lllc COIIII: lu()/( I Il)l:i( [' (Jr Llll~ cl,-lilll ur LI J(~ rJcLil.iIJl)( ~I JVI'lllltll • c.LI!J:;CqUCIIUV, ill (luul"(l,lIILC wiLli Llle' '~CJII~III(~ ilIJIJI-(IVCII I,V llle',IIIIII!IIII' I IIC r d I I I (' , I lIe ill ) I ) C " .. " (' .. I I II III I I i I V • W(lS LIlliS COllterlclell (III !-Jelled! IIi" IIIC IlPlil>iuIICIS/\I(~II(llII" \.11,11 111(' arllle.sC1icl lilclel c:1c~C1II)/ ill(lical:I:'s Lil;ll III(~ ;::lllll(>,II;:de ;;Illl.llulilV ill 111<' l"II,If\/I( -, "'::1 . 11'1 rel)u1:l:,iI, CUlfll:;c! 1(11 I II (' I':~:; I I (J I )( I F' I 11 /1\11 ) 1\11 ( " ( Ii', I I I II ( '( I I II ( , -;) cI (011 E' eli \I c I V , i I. i ~, cI ( '; I , III ill I 111 ~ I )t-' I iii () I I L~ I ' , (ell II I ul (I <i i " I . II I ·e • scilcrnc:s JlI-elJllred Ily L1lc loc'll L"1I1111(lliLir::, ill ('Ilc I\I,-d.ion('d C~lJlli{;-11 1('llilrll)! of' Delhi rOI-f"(:~SJUlilLi()11 or III'/..Jilil '"IYE'I'I V('llrIUI:,. Irl ',\llx~lilllli;'il(~ 111(' ',;'lirl il r en e:~ CI i 1.'.1 /\ eL, IN " i (II II I e II Li U II ~, I lIE' r (' I II. I II ,'I L iJ II I 11E~ :.; c II e II I c r ; I II (~I I, II (' I I I I \I 11 e I u c '.iI (w III c) I'i lie sill III C 1\1 Lll i I ) II ,II C " 1.1 il,'11 Tell i I. I ) I)! I I r I' J I 'II Ii I II ) I c9" llJLi(J11 uf UrlJcll1 .';1.1 eel \/Clllhll:; ill ill:1 (ll rl'-lIlcr~ witll 111e: 1\li'I! illflid 1'()lil Y )11 UI'L),lrl ~~LI:('cL \Iellclul-r~, 2()()1) (JIII.I I lire' IVI,T.,lr:'I' I'lem fUI' IJ(:lIli )(),' I, 11,1\/(: perl illlldc~lnelll'cci c"!rlel rllltl)(:1 111,,1 IlIlllI: lillie i:; l(o;llllirell rlll 111111,c'l TIj.ilcII1CIII:iJLioll (If Llle ')('.Il(';!I Il':'; IClj('il'(lillCj Il<lwkE,'IS ;:md

1.111'''1) :,111:1:1 /1, /\ :'I,)(::cific lefrlCllI,r Wil'; 111('lllr: 1))1 !.II!: ICull'lt:"ll UJI II 1:-;(:1 "('1111(' ICSIJUI'lrJcIlL/I\IUIVIC lu c;cl-lillll >'( 1.)(1) or l.lli' ~:'IIr:(.iLiI r'l()vi,,;i()II';, /\1 i, INllilll (1J::.~LcIlI1.8 Llclll~;e, lu :,,1 <Ilc' III,I!' ',(,7(1.1', Illlt! willi I ('I:liJ/(111.1 111(' (:11('111<1111111('111 CI' IlilZl1li.llllliZE-'cl r.iE..!\!f.:I(JIIIII('nl' ,I:; (III () 1,1) 1,/~()()Cl, I IIC!IILiI)II!:,(I ill 1111' ',,'Iit! I.I'U\!i~;iUII, INtiS ill Illc cOlllc!)(I, rl/' Llw II('[il'filil)1I Id' IIII,! 1111111',(", ":ncl-o,!clllrlenL" ,111(1 "11I1<IlIlhl')li?('11 II{'\.'(·'I()II"'~'III" ',1.:1 (Jlli ill Illc 111'lillilill/i cause ,:II. ::-~ccLiu/i,; )(1.)(\) <'!lid ;'(I)(i) 11»!';llc\.livf,~ly rd' 111(' "III'li,iI • c.'lse, II: WLlS slILJlTlil,Lr'rl 111<11. 1:1-1(' :~'IIC(,ii:ll l'I(I\/i:~i(ln:" I\ll, wlli( 111,,'1111(' illill prrecL ill Ihe yeel! 20(l! ,311(,1 Il"~~ 1100.11 f?)(lplJ(lcd rlill" UIJJ(' II) lillll' ,llId l("lsl'ly, lill DecerIJlJ(~I-JUII, (111(~r; IIUl. lji\I'~ r)l~rlni:<;illll II) 1'10.1:',1111,'; III I': '.1;111 Clil V iJ eli \I i L)! (J 11 C P. L/I e)l h;:1 veil (~ r~ I I I.: I 11 ':) \! (' l,l h )1 I I I C r: i \I i ( , ,II" III II i 1)1 ;-11 If I ::;i1Ililillly, Lhc SChClllC (lr )()()':} (Jcl('::, 1If,IL f'lllillc L11(~ J'(~~:}i:,IIlIIJ\'; III ',(1 11011 '-'Illes c; L1le)! Ili'I\lE:: I)PPII ,:-"111\1('11 ,1,"1)('1 inr: ~,il(", III ~jlll'II)(JI'- (If: LlII': ;1/1111",<Jiil c;ulJnlisc;i(JrI, 1001i'IIICe W<J(; 1:J!rwe 1111 IIIP 'i'.lr.l~,}IJ'lI-'III: ill IIle C'I:';r. Id' IVIC.LI v:" LO

1.11(: .illcJ\:Jlllelit I)r Ill(: "111 11(:'111(' «(11111 ill !IIC l,I~,C ()I IVILlllil,illdl :::'QU2Q.LQ.u()JL,oL_C;I:"Qi1U-;~J._ LlQII.\L',L!,V 13 .. ()J ~ ___ ~'S. l[LLiLCJI:L !)il ,~UIIJUI,]LiuII Ll,t.!. r tte5_~r:::,JJlla Ii] L .c,::_OJ:,lLl~~L (\L<::II, LIIJ ILLeLI \!~,'_ S L<::l LrLQL jJi II Q 1.- 01.., Q! J, I I ~I 1I1I I "I I "'.; L9~Tf (:S;IUIII~IJJJ) sec :VJI~il III ';liI:JIIJi! III,-JI ill 1IIIIill'")! lel}," (UIIIIIJ!Il!illll, 1111' elll) ";/n/us 17un' ilJ'JlJlic c, !lIE: "),i'·,lil!l.1 ~,I,~JiI' III' Illilll),,1'11 i'lIl)! (li\(r~11 1)lli,,! II/ ilne. I,) . /-\ s r U I III c 1\1 i:J Li l I 1'1 ill I) (11 i I Y <. II I I II I I '-11 I ';{ I (~(~ I \I I:~ I If.! (J I '" I (I I II I' ,1,1 II I I I II' ' I _SI.lUI'dfC>II!/I\JDlvIC :-;l;lll't1 !IIi'll, LI(II/I, !l1(' )r)(YI 1)(llir)! i'lili/ 1/)(' )(JlJIJ IHIlil \1, fllC.! Illi.'11Liuli ill Ill!' ('c'Ci~,i(JfI ,d' IIIC~ :,III!I('III!' r:(IUI!. ill IIlc~ (,1',0. ,J/ ',"lill!.lil f QIJ-LJ;;J-llJliJ) i'lllcI it lNil~; {lilly ilrh'l lilkill(1 iril(l lllll',i(I(~I,:"illli 1111' ';,Ji(1 lil..ic~;, Ilili the CUIlII IliIC'r'II"11 III" ili~,II!l.Ililllll'Jii,',llillli (1/' 111/1.-111 '.111'1'1 IIClilltJ lIIlUUt;'111 1(~~li:,I,:'Il'illli. It lNil', l'IIIl/I(.'1 ';I,Il,eel I'.ilill ell

1.1)(' lillll' (il l It cl eli \I eli 11 ~I L il e j II cJ~) 11 I (" I II I 1,11 C' (I i ~ , J (I ) r I I U, III (! ~~; l: I,ll C I ) I e (_~ ( ) I ,,[ I () ( ) k I II " i I I' or L1w 1\1 C T () f [) E' I h i I, ,,111\1 ~, C,; jl (' ( i iJ I 1'1' ( ) vis i ( ) I I';) /\ C I, ) U Cl ( ), IN I Ii\. I I IN i'I:; \I i did U jJ L 1.1 ] {j , 12,20 ,I U, ( I' r Cli. C C til) 11 I) f Ii V cI i h II U (I III 11 J I \ fC~ ~,II I I ,-I Ii I ) n I. ) f'.:; I: I l! r~ I: \I ( ! 11 d i I Il)) I 'oj II , / I I ( I' ) inLloclllCCcJ b), LlIC' C-;OVI'I'IIIllc!IIL or ]IILiicl, 1'Ilillir;[I\f t)r Ilull':;illl.} ::1

(111)<111 p () \! e r L i' /\" e \I i cd, i elll, ',J I 1(:,' ',I i'I! c (I Lli ill I 1(.' L II i I I~) I lew i:, I I (J IN I) (-! i I III :, I II ) I II i I I (' ( I by l./ie IlcLiti(Jllel'c;/vE.~I](I(.lI;; Ilen!in, fUI' 1'110' I.)I'(::.!:';clli 1)('~lili(III" II) 1,(· 12lltcl'[iJilleci FOI' lilly 1)III'rll):~r 'VVIIl"I[r;I)(:VC'I- ;111(1 <III UIP. ~)I'if;V,'I'lr:cc~ I ;li',I:11 1')1 [11<:: \I I'll I I i III I CCJlTlIl'liUCE'/C:'1JP(:,II(I!E:~ f:lllllllll'il:V 1I11I1e'l l/ie' r;( 11('11')(" )'(,:1 ilU "(,) II) 1111,,111 ',111'1'1 verlcJirllj in lhe I\IUIVJC l"IIC,l, Wllkll fUILI l'_lI'1LiIIIiC Lo ICi'lIf1ill fUlillil)lI i'd, I'\I(~II \/illi<III', 11)11I1:,cl', fl)I' I.IIC IlclililJlleICC;/vcllIl()I'; ,111111111' I:Z~)/,}l(; .. l.,'-'~liJ) illlplie~", 1110 /eillllllii( III' 111e' ;'11'(11111)('111:; ll(JcIICS:,(!11 II11 111,/1,111 or 1/ Jr:' pel iUUI'l(:Ts/vr;/I( I(II:J i', 111;:11' I I liC~ ',I ;llll~; CillO (II (lei' )(:il( I wil I I I I II' Cj U ,~iI i r)1 i II ~I ,\f\I U r cl 5 ( "il~; i [ i', I) I I [ "i II i 11 Lj I ()( 1,-, y", : .11 U i)(,: II I.C) I I I (! () I I I I! I, I ,III I'll I Y be I'("~'III [0 ill/ply """, ,'I r , (III lIill(:, i,e" '1",1 ,,'l) I I,

1.11(,:1(; \I\Ii'I~; /II) ';( 111'1111' 0l'Jerelli())),:" ill IIw I\IUIVIC' 01(:,1:; 1.1.1 11'(1111;:01,(' \lPII(Iil')(1 ,')([ivilir"; ,111(/ !ill ,I 1,11111 & is ulLimalely enLlctecl by tile Icgisl,)lul"e, ,111 the petitioner"s, ilTespecLivc of theil-legal status, can continue .sCju("lltinq/I"luwking at diffel-ent sites that have been occupied by lhen1-It is (Jlso asser-ted that in the teeth of the status quo orders passed by the Supr-emc Cour-t, the respondentjl\IDMC in collusion with thc police authorilies, is threatening to illegally rel110Vf~ tile petitioners/vendor-s frolll diffel-erll sites, which is detr-imental, advel-sc, harassing and belligel-ent to those, who have been found eligible by the respondent/NOMC fOI-being allottcd specific L"ehbazari spaces within the NOMC jurisdiction, but al-e beiny LlJr(~atelled due to lack of furthel-acLion in this r-egard which is pending at the end of the respondent/NDIViC. rhe second liml) of SUblllissiollS macle by tile learned counsels fOI-tile petitioners/vendors was tllat the Special I)rovisions /-\ct would additionally come to the r·escue of the pel ilioners/vencior"S, which also I-equircs maintenarlce of status quo as existing on 01.10.2006, till the end of Oeccmbel-, 2011.

¶27On the ol/wr-hallel, the main thrust of the arguments ac.ldressecl by the coullsel fOI-L1le I espolldellVI\ID~!JC was that as the Icgislatul-e hus failed t:o enact an appropl-iClte legi~;ICltioll in term::; of the deCision of tile Supr-cme Court in lIle cuse of G~lfllL(LRglJJ.(s.~LQrCl1, the subsequcnt o,·c1cl-datec.l 1~).7.2011 (lin~ctill~J IJurLic:s to maintain the status quo iJS it is obtaining on the saici c.lale can (mly imply lhat the state of affiJirs as existing 011 date alc not to lJe disturbed, lrntil the l-ighLs of tile partie~; call be fillally c1etennined througil Icgi:::lation. IL was submitLed that whilc W.fJ.(C) 4743/2011,5254/2011 & connected lI1aHers i I)LlSsill~1 ll1c c.,LClI:lIS quo (Jllir'l- (III 1~-J.c)7_/ULl, IIIC ~~;III)ICIIIC~ (\11111 \I\Iil', SCJuLlttill~J Ileilll'"'1 unclel Ill(' "eIIClu,lclIIIIClll", 1101 1I11(1C'1 "lllli'1l1l11IJI-i7prl (Irvell'I'lllrl-II"" II \1\1,1'; rlllllll'l II i', i"Ii', I I \I t' I ',I ill I JJ ill C I I [, 1.11 111 [I W I 1 I I ~ i 11 I i I II J 1\1 I) I 111 II V III i'" loq9E'lhe.i:lcIS 011 Lhe C()(IIJ)IJc,il i( III (II' 111e' ,lcljutliCiJ II 11)f 11ll'c1I~11 Ji~.111 ill 1111' 1\1 D IVI C j 1I1 is (I i c li () II <'1fl cl

1.1 H: ! I 1 illil I f_' I uri 1<; rIll Ie Li (II I i I I U, ,I c:; <.11 ;.d I til c: i I I I ' I 11 i I )I 111(' lJ\III~1 .i·"'(I(~:. ur UIP leU"I]I- .1-I.frlclllll'lll I I I )" I( L _ - I ,-I [' [ , I" J.: () I (J i I I 1/ I l' I ,~I'. ( ~ [ Ii llt.1i II d II I I II ' Li}(:'111, '~ r,-wL(lI, Wllil,11 i'~ 111,'11 -I' '1-1111" 'III() I I I - " ' , , I) I, I ~ II ii' CJUU. 11 (I[ n 111)1 I Ji I ) cI~, ,1" I II (~ I) 0 I Li I '~, [I) I II I.) <l '-Ij I I eli l iJ I.i () I I, ,1 I I (i ,-III 1 II (' I) ,-II I i I :' . , I i \I i I ClI-jucliciL-i/ who ,-:IIE' 1C'IIuilf:d If) ,,( I ill clel ul'IIillln' willi 1111" ~,;·lid (11111'1'., lilli il: E'l)lIilll)' hillds 1111:; I'Iil/ll (~(l\1I1. rlllln ililc'lfcliliCI wiLli ~'III.II ell I (lilil'l, ,,'. IIw siJic! ol'del' has 11er.'11 I_)'lsscr.I ill lilil./,"iOll~; tlcfun: [11f: Ili~,JI1C:,1 1:111111 {I/ 1111' lanel, U I Tk~ 1-i <~ .J r. I e ell ,-; i (,/1 I" I I r)

1.11 C I Ii CJ I I (: ( I U I I ,I ~~ IN I~ ", I (I 'J \I () i (I ~ II , II II i I I (/ ,II I )' l) n.l C I, ill C I u rj i 11 ~I il nil ilY I i I II (I I I I I' I, IN I len I I Ie:' , 1I1 ) I r: I I I (~ : () III I I I i'l :, I I i I (' { I I '{ I . r CI I :.1 <:11.1.1 S ( /11 U 1 () L) c n 1,1 i III "i II r' 1/ . I II ',[ I {. I I ( i I I I II II ',; I ,If I (P. ';, i r III i'; I I I III I \i\I"'; 10 S-JI,:l1l1 il ';1(1)1 orl/.'I ill f;'11I1111I Ilf 1/',' I)I'!.ilill!l!:'1 (;/VC:IIlIlll " .111(1)/1'11 111'11111: illLr'I/JI(:lilLi(JI) [Ir 1.11(' ',1,1111" (II Iii (111./1'1, iL Wll', 11I1 !.Ilelli III /li'I\IC' i'I/lidil'rilll 1118 ;';IIII1CI111? «(Jllil rl)1 11<lI'i/il,l/illll'; 1I)('rr~()r, /\r/clilil)/)("I)I, III!' II,Ii;'IIIII' p/illCII I»), Lhe I)E'l.ilil)ll(~I:;/\/(:lII/(II-'; (lil 1111' (-,/)('1 iell l)r(I\/i.~,il)ll', /\11 '.c'I:ldlll/ illLf'lilll I (-'(,./rl I :":llll,lil.)1 1(1 Ii'll.' Ii/"(('IIICIl! Ilr 1/()()I_h Ily 1111:111 1I1I 1111' POVCII'eI1Ls, I)), LC:'llllill~1 il ICCOlJlli~-f::'(1 I./I)(ICI" IIIf' ';;'lid 1\(1 ;:tllli 111('il (ll/llr:'II[j1111 11,,-,11111' .',1'1 111 '1111' CCILlII helrl Iccnl,-111i7.r:'li l.IlI~ ril' I. Illtl/ IIiI~ :_'I)('Li;'II I)III\li';il.lII~; /\1 Ii', iI)(' (1111)1 (-·eIIIILlllew\! h'll!ill~J Illilll;-I()1 11\1('10111"1 (,1,'111111", ,1/(: ,-II,d) 11'1.111('1'.111,111111: _ ,I Ol)il"liOl1 Illill it \l\Iill Ilul-LIe' (11l1 11(1pli"Lc: ((11 il [U I:,llilnl: ::;L~IY (11(/('1'; ill 1111' f,lll: the ~jllIHC:IIIC CrJl.lIl, wlliell 11l1l~;L I:)(~ 1('~;IW(If'rll_")I.II, ill Idlc~1 illlli ~'Idlil, III , rJ7, (Jc-rC)[I{(l),t,\, 2U f J I'kh ( 1/ 1/ .It 1/\11 #~ I/{ It III/ fi 1/ II , 1IJ1)(;1

* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI + w.p.eel 4347/2011. 4650/2011, 4651/2011, 5028/2011. 4775/2011. 5257/2011. 5258/2011. 5264/2011. 5277/2011, 5402/2011. 5403/2011, 5411/2011, 5413/2011, 5473/2011. 5484/2011, 5503/2011, 5504/2011, 5508/2011, 5595/2011, 5618/2011, 5627/2011, 5645/2011, 5654/2011. 5718/2011, 5728/2011, 5737/2011, 5738/2011, 5784/2011. 5785/2011, 5798/2011. 5822/2011, 5931/2011, 5933/2011, 5965/2011, 5966/2011, 5970/2011. 597412011, 6102/2011, 6107/2011, 6116/2011. 6117/2011. 6121/2011. 6122/2011, 6270/2011, 6271/2011, 6529/2011. 6530/2011, 6534/2011, 6538/2011. 6669/2011, 6670/2011, 4739/2011, 5046/2011, 4722/2011, 2601/2011, 3185/2011, 3189/2011, 4343/2011, 4344/2011. 4352/2011, 4354/2011, 4360/2011, 4361/2011, 4365/2011, 4366/2011. 437~/2011. 4371/2011, 4375/2011. 4377/2011, 4391/2011. 4392/2011, ~398J2011, 4398/2011, 4404/2011. 4405/2011, 4409/2011, 4410/2011, 5341/2011, 4847/2011, Reserved on : 21.09.2011 Pronounced on: 24.10.2011 4559/2011. 4593/2011. 4827/2011. 4923/2011. 5247/2011, 5254/2011. 5261/2011. 5~62/2011. 5292/2011, 5312/2011. 5405/2011. 5408/2011. 5418/2011, 5423/2011. 5485/2011, 5497/2011. 5505/2011, 5506/2011, 5614/2011, 5615/2011, 5630t2011, 5631/2011. 5656/2011, 5711/2011. 5729/2011, 5731/2011. 5739/2011,5743/2011. 5791/2011, 5794/2011, 5911/2011, 5918/2011, 5934/2011. 5935/2011. 5967/2011, 5968/2011. 6096/2011. 6100/2011, 6108/211. 6114/2011, 6118/2011, 6119/2011. 6123/2011, 6144/2011. 6449/2011, 6527/2011, 6531/2011. 6532/2011, 6555/2011, 6667/2011. 6684/2011, 6701/2011. 5051/2011, 5157/2011. 2602/2011. 3052/2011, 3196/2011, 4340/2011, 4345/2011, 4349/2011. 4356/2011, 4358/2011, 4362/2011, 4363/2011. 4367/2011, 4368/2011, 4372/2011, 4373/2Qll. 4387/2011, 4388/2011, 4393/2011, 4395/2011, 4399/2011, 4400/2011. 4406/2011, 4407/2011, 4412/2011, 4413/2011. 4859/2011, 4887/2011, 4610/2011. 5024/2011. 5255/2011. 5263/2011. 5317/2011. 5410/2011, 5444/2011, 5498/2011, 5507/2011, 5616/2011, 5643/2011, 5717/2011, 5732/2011, 5761/2011, 5797/2011, 5928/2011, 5957/2011, 5969/2011, 6101/2011. 6115/2011, 6120/2011, 6250/2011. 6528/2011, 6533/2011, 6668/2011, 5173/2011, 4649/2011, 3181/2011, 4342/2011, 4350/2011, 4359/2011. 4364/2011, 4369/2011. 4374/2011, 4389/2011, 4396/2011, 4402/2011, 4408/2011, 4414/2011, 4990/2011. W.P.(C) 4347/2011 and connected matters Page 10'8 Certify that the digital file and physical file have been compared and the digital data is as per the physical file and no page is missing. , , 5063/201L 5089/2011, 5099/2011, 5114/2011, 5115/2011, 5117/2011, 5129/2011, 5139/2011, 5144/2011, 6708/2011, 6799/2011, 6824/2011, 6825/2011, 6826/2011, 6827/2011, 6896/2011, 6901/2011, 6902/2011, 6903/2011, 6904/2011, 6905/2011, 6906/2011, 6907/2011, 6908/2011, 6909/2011, 6910/2011, 6917/2011, 6919/2011, 6920/2011, 6921/2011, 6922/2011. 6932/2011 and 5420/2011. IN THE MATTERS OF MOHD. AZAD ..... Petitioner in W.P.(C) 4347/2011 MOHD: ALAM ..... Petitioner in W.P.(C) 4559/2011 KIRPAL SINGH ..... Petitioner in W.P.(C) 4593/2011 SHAILENDER KUMAR ..... Petitioner in W.P.(C) 4610/2011 SANJAY ..... Petitioner in W.P.(C) 4650/2011 BABLU ..... Petitioner in W.P.(C) 4651/2011 AMAR NATH SINGH ..... Petitioner in W.P.(C) 4827/2011 GANESH PRASAD ..... Petitioner in W.P.(C) 4923/2011 BHUPAL SINGH ..... Petitioner in W.P.(C) 5024/2011 SURENDER SINGH AND ORS. .. ... Petitioners in W.P.(C) 5028/2011 USHA ..... Petitioner in W.P.(C) 4775/2011 RAKESH KUMAR AND ORS. .. ... Petitioners in W.P.(C) 5247/2011 RAM DASS ..... Petitioner in W.P.(C) 5254/2011 VISHAMBAR JHA ..... Petitioner in W.P.(C) 5255/2011 DINESH KUMAR ..... Petitioner in W.P.(C) 5257/2011 ANJU ..... Petitioner in W.P.(C) 5258/2011 RAJESH C GUPTA AND ORS. .. ... Petitioners in W.P.(C) 5261/2011 LAKHPATI AND ORS. . .... Petitioners in W.P.(C) 5262/2011 SOHAN LAL AND ORS. .. ... Petitioners in W.P.(C) 5263/2011 KEDARI ..... Petitioner in W.P.(C) 5264/2011 ARUN KUMAR ALIAS LUCKY ..... Petitioner in W.P.(C) 5277/2011 MITHU LAL ..... Petitioner in W.P.