Manjeet Singh & Anr v. Hargobind Singh & Anr

V.B.GUPTA, J. mw

* HIGH COURT OF DELHI : NEW DELHI 1. CM(M) No. 947/2010 & CM No. 13139/2010 % Judgment reserved on: 1st September, 2010 Judgment delivered on: 30th September, 2010 1. Sh. Prabhjot Singh & Anr. S/o Sh. Teja Singh, 2. Sh. Balbir Singh S/oSh. Gurjit Singh R/o Village Behat, Tehsil Bilaspur, District Rampur, U.P. ….Petitioners. Through: Mr. M.S.Vinayak with Mr. Deepak, Advocates. Versus 1. Col. (Retd.) Hargobind Singh S/o late Gurbaksh Singh R/o House No. 1394, Sector-33C, Chandigarh. 2. Sh.Hargursaran Singh S/o late Gurbaksh Singh R/o Village Behat, Tehsil Bilaspur District Rampur, U.P. ….Respondents Through: None 2. CM (M) No. 948/2010 & CM No. 13146/2010 1. Smt. Namrata Chandi D/o Sardar Hargursharan Singh Through her attorney Sh.Harbans Singh Son of Inder Singh R/o Village Behat, Tehsil Bilaspur District Rampur, U.P. ….Petitioner Through: Mr. M.S.Vinayak with Mr. Deepak, Advocates. Versus 1. Smt. Amrinder Kaur D/o Sh. Hargobind Singh Address for service R/o House No. 1394, Sector-33C, Chandigarh. 2. Sh.Hargursaran Singh S/o late Gurbaksh Singh R/o Village Behat, Tehsil Bilaspur District Rampur, U.P. ….Respondents Through: None 3. CM (M) No. 950/2010 & CM No. 13168/2010 1. Sh. Manjeet Singh S/o Sh. Jagir Singh 2. Sh. Balbir Singh S/o Sh. Gurdeep Singh (Both represented through Sh. Teja Singh son of Sh. Gurdit Singh R/o Village Behat, Tehsil Bilaspur District Rampur, U.P. ….Petitioners Through: Mr. M.S.Vinayak with Mr. Deepak, Advocates Versus 1. Col. (Retd.)Sh. Hargobind Singh S/o late Gurbaksh Singh R/o House No. 1394, Sector-33C, Chandigarh. 2. Sh.Hargursaran Singh S/o late Gurbaksh Singh R/o Village Behat, Tehsil Bilaspur District Rampur, U.P. ….Respondents Through: None 4. CRP No. 134/2010 & CM No. 13095/2010 Hargursharan Singh Major, S/o Sh. Sardar Gurbaksh Singh, R/o Village Bihta, Tehsil Bilaspur District Rampur, U.P. ….Petitioner Through: Petitioner in person Versus 1. Col. Sh. Hargobind Singh Through attorney Parminder Kaur, R/o House No. 1394, Sector-33C, Chandigarh. ….Respondent No.1 2. Prabhjot Singh Major, S/o Sh. Tej Singh, R/o Village Bihta, Tehsil Bilaspur District Rampur, U.P. …Respondent No.2 3. Balbir Singh Major, S/o Sh. Gurjit Singh, R/o Village Bihta, Tehsil Bilaspur District Rampur, U.P. ….Respondent No.3 Through: None 5. CRP No. 135/2010 & CM No. 13097/2010 Hargursharan Singh Major, S/o Sh. Sardar Gurbaksh Singh, R/o Village Bihta, Tehsil Bilaspur District Rampur, U.P. ….Petitioner Through: Petitioner in person Versus 1. Col. Sh. Hargobind Singh Through attorney Parminder Kaur, R/o House No. 1394, Sector-33C, Chandigarh. ….Respondent No.1 2. Mangit Singh Major, S/o Sh. Jagir Singh, R/o Village Behait, Tehsil Bilaspur District Rampur, U.P. …Respondent No.2 3. Balbir Singh Major, S/o Sh. Gurjit Singh, R/o Village Behait, Tehsil Bilaspur District Rampur, U.P. ….Respondent No.3 Through: None 6. CRP No. 136/2010 & CM No. 13098/2010 Hargursharan Singh Major, S/o Sh. Sardar Gurbaksh Singh, R/o Village Bihta, Tehsil Bilaspur District Rampur, U.P. ….Petitioner Through: Petitioner in person Versus 1. Smt. Amrinder Kaur Col. Sh. Hargobind Singh Through attorney Parminder Kaur, R/o House No. 1394, Sector-33C, Chandigarh. ….Respondent No.1 2. Colonel Sarvajit Singh Thind, S/o Sh.Avtar Singh Thind, R/o Village Bihta, Tehsil Bilaspur District Rampur, U.P. …Respondent No.2 3. Namrita Chandi, D/o Sh. Hargursharan Singh, R/o Village Bihta, Tehsil Bilaspur District Rampur, U.P. ….Respondent No.3 Through: None Coram: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.B. GUPTA 1. Whether the Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes 2. To be referred to Reporter or not? Yes 3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Yes V.B.Gupta, J. By this common judgment, above said six petitions are being disposed of, since common question of law and facts are involved in these petitions. 2. Brief facts are that, Col. Hargobind Singh Major, respondent herein (plaintiff in the trial court) through his attorney Smt. Parminder Kau