A.K.Iyyappan v. R.Thavamani

ORDER We make it clear that interim stay granted in this appeal would enure only in favour of the appellants in A.S.(MD)No.216 of 2018, A.S.(MD)No.20 of 2020, A.S.(MD)No.277 of 2021, A.S.(MD)No.122 of 2021 & A.S.(MD)No.163 of 2018. In other words, the persons who are not appellants before this Court cannot claim the benefit of the interim order. This Civil Miscellaneous Petition is disposed of accordingly. [G.R.S.J.,] & [R.K.M.J.,]

04.02.2026 rmi To

¶1R.Thavamani S/o. Late Raman C-53 East Street Tiruparankundram Madurai - 625 003.

¶2R.Moorthi S/o. Late. Raman C-53 East Street Tiruparankundram Madurai - 625 003.

¶3Venkatesan Door No. 530 Gokhale Road Pandian Nagar Narayanapuram Madurai - 625014. Ammapillai Ammal (Died).

¶4Rajamani W/o.Shanmugam Door No. 4/307 Bharathidasan Street Sadhasiva Nagar Madurai - 625 020.

¶5Sarojini W/o.P.M. Subramanian Bank Colony Narayanapuram Madurai - 625014.

¶6Meenakshi D/o. Ramasamy Konar Door No. 4/307 Bharathidasan Street Sadhasiva Nagar madurai - 625 020 S. Tirumalai @ Mani (Died).

¶7S. Ramachandran S/o.Solaimalaikonar Door No. 14 State Bank Colony Bye-pass Colony Ponmeni Madurai - 625 016.

¶8S.Govindan S/o.Solaimalikonar Door No. 64 West AvaniMoola Street Madurai - 625 001.

¶9S.Manickam S/o.Solaimalai Konar Door No. 93-6 Arul nagar Opposite to PRC Bye-pass Road Madurai - 625 016.

¶10S.Srinivasan S/o.Solaimalai Konar Door No 64 West AvaniMoola Street Madurai - 625 001.

¶11Saraswathi D/o. Solaimalai Konar Door No. 63 Kanagavel Colony Madurai - 625 001.

¶12Rani D/o. Solaimalai Konar Vanasankari yadavar Street Ramanathapuram.

¶13Jeya D/o. Kumarasamy Door No. 64 West AvaniMoola Street Madurai - 625 001.

¶14Ravi Son of Kumarasamy Door No. 64 West AvaniMoola Street Madurai - 625001 C. Arthur (Died)

¶15S.Suriyakanthi Ammal Wife of E.M. Subramanian Door No. 131 Pandia Vellalar Street Madurai E.M.S. Mohan (DIed).

¶16E.M.S.Sukumaran Son of E.M. Subramanian Door No. 131 PandiaVellala Street Madurai E.M.S. Paramasivam (Died)

¶17E.M.S. Sudhakar Son of E.M. Subramanian Door No. 131 Pandia Vellalar Street Madurai. E.M.S. Manikandan (Died)

¶18E.M.S.Senthilkumari Daughter of E.M. Subramanian Door No. 131 Pandia Vellalar Street Madurai.

¶19E.M.S. Velmurugan Son of E.M. Subramanian Door No. 131 Pandia Vellalar Street Madurai V. Chelliah (Died) R. Muniammal @ Selvarathi (Died)

¶20R.Sagarban Beevi Wife of S. Liykath Ali Door No. 2 AttumandhaiPottal Fourth Lane East Veli Street Madurai.

¶21K. Pappathi Ammal Wife of Kamatchi nadar Door No. 28-A New Ramanathapuram Road Madurai 625009.

¶22K. Vairamuthu (Exonerated) Son of Kaliappa Nadar Door No. 15 Pankajam Colony Madurai 625009.

¶23Jayalakshmi Trading Company Through one of its Partners Murugan (Exonerated) Business at No. 2 Vengalakadai Street First Lane Madurai 625001.

¶24G. Balasubramanian Traders Through one of its Partners Subbaiah (Exonerated) Business at No. 2 Vengalakadai Street First Lane Madurai 625 001.

¶25Thayagam Traders Through one of its Partners Rajasekaran (Exonerated) Business at No. 2 Vengalakadai Street First Lane Madurai 625001.

¶26Super Star Chemicals Through one of its Partners James (Exonerated) Business at No.2 Vengalakadai Street First Lane Madurai 625001.

¶27Dhakshinamoorthy (Exonerated) Proprietor Senthil Traders Business at No. 2 Vengalakadai Street First Lane Madurai 625001.

¶28Jeyamani Trading Company Through one of its Partners Jeyamani (Exonerated) Business at No. 3A Vengalakadai Street First Lane Madurai 625001.

¶29Sri Anadavar and Co. Through one of its Partners Mahendran (Exonerated) Business at No. 2 Vengalakadai Street First Lane Madurai 625001.

¶30S.Sundaresan (Exonerated) Son of S.T. Subramaniapillai Tractor Workshop Door No. 12 PerumalKovil Street Talakulam Madurai 625002.

¶31Mariammal (Exonerated) Wife of Mark Business at No. 12 PerumalKovil Street Tallakulam Madurai 625002.

¶32S.Siddharthan (Exonerated) Son of SonaiMudaliar DRO Road Opposite Lakshmi Theatre K.Pudur Madurai 625 007.

¶33S.Sridharan (Exonerated) Scooter Workshop at No. 12 PerumalKoil Street Tallakulam Madurai 625002.

¶34Ramasamy Pillai (Exonerated) Business at No. 296 Big Car Street Thirupparankundram Madurai 625005.

¶35V.Subbiah (Exonerated) Son of Veerappa Naicker Door No. 297 Big Car Street Thirupparankundram Madurai 625005.

¶36S.Mariappan (Exonerated) Son of Sankaralingam Door No. 298 Big Car Street Thirupparankundram Madurai 625005.

¶37Ramaiah Chettiar (Exonerated) Son of Ramanathan Door No. 299 Big Car Street Thirupparankundram Madurai 625005.

¶38S.Muthu (Exonerated) Son of Sokkalingam Door No.300 Big Car Street Thirupparankundram Madurai 625005

¶39A.Dhanabalan (Exonerated) Son of Avadaiyappan Nadar Door No. 104 Swami Sannathi Street Madurai 625001.

¶40R.Ethiraj (Exonerated) Son of Ramasamy Naidu Business at No. 104 Upstairs Swami Sannathi Street Madurai 625001.

¶41S.Lakshmi Ammal (Exonerated) Wife of SubbiahKonar Sankar Colony nadar Street Thiruppuvanam.

¶42R.Nagendran (Exonerated) Son of Raja Pillai Business at No. 106 Swami Sannathi Street Madurai 625001.

¶43P.Murugesan Son of Palanisamy Servai Business at No. 107 Swami Sannathi Street Madurai 625001.

¶44L.Nachimuthu Chettiar (Exonerated) Business at No. 108 Swami Sannathi Street Madurai 625001.

¶45N.Murugesan (Exonerated) Son of NatarajaPillai Business at No. 109 Swami Sannathi Street Madurai 625001.

¶46R.N.Mahalinganadar and Co. Throgh R. Mhalinga Nadar Door No. 71 East masi Street Madurai - 625001.

¶47S.Liyakath Ali Stationery business at No. 72 East masi Street Madurai - 625001.

¶48K.Alagarsamy Son of kamatchi Nadar Business at No. 73 East masi Street Madurai - 625001.

¶49V. Santhaam Ambalam (Exonerated) Son of Veerabadra Ambalam Nedungulam Village Thiruvedagam Post Vadipatti Taluk Madurai District.

¶50V. Ambalam Alias Muthukaruppan (Exonerated) Son of Veerbadra Ambalam Nedungulam Village Thiruvedagam Post Vadipatti Taluk Madurai District.

¶51V. Chinnasamy Ambalam (Exonerated) Son of Veerbadra Ambalam Nedungulam Village Thiruvedagam Post Vadipatti Taluk Madurai District.

¶52Ramu Thevar (Exonerated) Nedungulam Village Thiruvedagam Post Vadipatti Taluk Madurai District.

¶53The Executive Officer Arulmigu Kallalagar Thirukkovil Alagarkovil Melur Taluk Madurai District.

¶54The Madurai City Municipal Corporation Through its Commissioner (Exonerated) Anna Maligai Alagarkovil Road Madurai - 625002.

¶55Kala Wife of P. Ganesan Sudanthira nagar Second Street Y. Othakadai Madurai North Taluk.

¶56Karmegam (Exonerated) Son of MottayandiMudaliar Door No. 10 Thiruvappudaiyarkoil Street Sellur Madurai.

¶57Kannan (Exonerated) Door No. 90 PandiaVellalar Street Madurai - 625001.

¶58S.K.M. Coffee Bar Through is Proprietor East Masi Street Madurai.

¶59S.Rajapillai (Exonerated) Door No. 106 Swami Sannathi Street madurai - 625001.

¶60M.Achikannu Wife of late E.M.S. Mohan Door No. 33/15 Thiruvalluvar Street K.K. Nagar Madurai - 625020.

¶61M.Sakthi Devi Daughter of late E.M.S. Mohan Door No. 33/15 Thiruvalluvar Street K.K. Nagar Madurai - 625020.

¶62M. Gayathiri Daughter of late E.M.S. Mohan Door No. 33/15 Thiruvalluvar Street K.K. Nagar Madurai - 625020.

¶63Minor.M.Sudharsan Son of late E.M.S. Mohan Door No. 33/15 Thiruvalluvar Street K.K. Nagar Madurai - 625020. (Represented through his mother/Guardian the 62nd Respondent)

¶64S.Seethalakshmi Wife of V. Chelliah Door No. 4/79 Second Street Sudanthira nagar Y. Othakadai Madurai North Taluk.

¶65Jeyaprakash Son of V. Chelliah Business at Prasanna Metal Works Main Road Y.Othakadai Madurai North Taluk.

¶66Velmurugan Son of V. Chelliah Business at lakshmi Grocery Shop Door No. 2/807 Narasingam Road Y.Othakadai Madurai North Taluk

¶67P.Muthulakshmi Wife of Late E.M.S. Paramasivam Door No. 7 Vasantha nagar Second Street Madurai - 625003.

¶68P.Senthamil Selvan Son of late E.M.S. Paramasivam Door No. 7 Vasantha Nagar Second Street Madurai - 625001.

¶69P.Prabahakaran Son of late E.M.S. Paramasivam Door No. 7 Vasantha nagar Second Street Madurai - 625003.

¶70P. Divya Daughter of Late E.M.S. Paramasivam Door No 7 Vasantha nagar Second Street Madurai - 625003.

¶71Latha Mangesh Wife of late E.M.S. Manikandan Door No. 5 Pookkara Street West Masi Street Madurai - 625001.

¶72Minor M.Rajkiran Son of late E.M.S. Manikandan Door No. 5 Pookkara Street West Masi Street Madurai - 625001. (Represented through his mother/Guardian the 71st Respondent)

¶73Minor M.Suriya Wife of late E.M.S. Manikandan Door No. 5 Pookkara Street West Masi Street Madurai - 625001. (Represented through his mother/Guardian the 71st Respondent)

¶74M.Selvaraj Door No. 135 Chitrakkara Street Madurai.

¶75S.Prabhu Son of M. Selvaraj Door No. 135 Chitrakkara Street Madurai.

¶76A. Kalpana Wife of C. Arthur Door No. 4 Kuppukillai lane South Veli Street Madurai.

¶77Vasu Son of C. Arthur Door No. 4 Kuppukillai lane South Veli Street Madurai.

¶78J. Latha Daughter of C. Arthur Door No. 4 Kuppukillai lane South Veli Street Madurai.

¶79Tiruppathi Son of C. Arthur Door No. 4 Kuppukillai lane South Veli Street Madurai.

CMP(MD) NO. 17343 of 2025 BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT DATED: 04-02-2026 CORAM THE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE G.R.SWAMINATHAN AND THE HONOURABLE MRS JUSTICE R. KALAIMATHI CMP(MD) NO. 17343 of 2025 IN AS(MD) NO. 277 OF 2021 1. A.K.Iyyappan S/o.A.Kuppusamy Konar For himself and as Trustee of Samayakone Trust Door No. 3 Vengalakadai First Lane Madurai - 625 001. Petitioner(s) Vs 1. R.Thavamani S/o. Late Raman C-53 East Street Tiruparankundram Madurai - 625 003. 2. R.Moorthi S/o. Late. Raman C-53 East Street Tiruparankundram Madurai - 625 003. 3. Venkatesan Door No. 530 Gokhale Road Pandian Nagar Narayanapuram Madurai - 625014. Ammapillai Ammal (Died). 4. Rajamani W/o.Shanmugam Door No. 4/307 Bharathidasan Street Sadhasiva Nagar Madurai - 625 020. 5. Sarojini W/o.P.M. Subramanian Bank Colony Narayanapuram Madurai - 625014. 6. Meenakshi D/o. Ramasamy Konar Door No. 4/307 Bharathidasan Street Sadhasiva Nagar madurai - 625 020 S. Tirumalai @ Mani (Died). 7. S. Ramachandran S/o.Solaimalaikonar Door No. 14 State Bank Colony Bye-pass Colony Ponmeni Madurai - 625 016. 8. S.Govindan S/o.Solaimalikonar Door No. 64 West AvaniMoola Street Madurai - 625 001. 9. S.Manickam S/o.Solaimalai Konar Door No. 93-6 Arul nagar Opposite to PRC Bye-pass Road Madurai - 625 016. 10. S.Srinivasan S/o.Solaimalai Konar Door No 64 West AvaniMoola Street Madurai - 625 001. 11. Saraswathi D/o. Solaimalai Konar Door No. 63 Kanagavel Colony Madurai - 625 001. 12. Rani D/o. Solaimalai Konar Vanasankari yadavar Street Ramanathapuram. 13. Jeya D/o. Kumarasamy Door No. 64 West AvaniMoola Street Madurai - 625 001. 14. Ravi Son of Kumarasamy Door No. 64 West AvaniMoola Street Madurai - 625001 C. Arthur (Died) 15. S.Suriyakanthi Ammal Wife of E.M. Subramanian Door No. 131 Pandia Vellalar Street Madurai E.M.S. Mohan (DIed). 16. E.M.S.Sukumaran Son of E.M. Subramanian Door No. 131 PandiaVellala Street Madurai E.M.S. Paramasivam (Died) 17. E.M.S. Sudhakar Son of E.M. Subramanian Door No. 131 Pandia Vellalar Street Madurai. E.M.S. Manikandan (Died) 18. E.M.S.Senthilkumari Daughter of E.M. Subramanian Door No. 131 Pandia Vellalar Street Madurai. 19. E.M.S. Velmurugan Son of E.M. Subramanian Door No. 131 Pandia Vellalar Street Madurai V. Chelliah (Died) R. Muniammal @ Selvarathi (Died) 20. R.Sagarban Beevi Wife of S. Liykath Ali Door No. 2 AttumandhaiPottal Fourth Lane East Veli Street Madurai. 21. K. Pappathi Ammal Wife of Kamatchi nadar Door No. 28-A New Ramanathapuram Road Madurai 625009. 22. K. Vairamuthu (Exonerated) Son of Kaliappa Nadar Door No. 15 Pankajam Colony Madurai 625009. 23. Jayalakshmi Trading Company Through one of its Partners Murugan (Exonerated) Business at No. 2 Vengalakadai Street First Lane Madurai 625001. 24. G. Balasubramanian Traders Through one of its Partners Subbaiah (Exonerated) Business at No. 2 Vengalakadai Street First Lane Madurai 625 001. 25. Thayagam Traders Through one of its Partners Rajasekaran (Exonerated) Business at No. 2 Vengalakadai Street First Lane Madurai 625001. 26. Super Star Chemicals Through one of its Partners James (Exonerated) Business at No.2 Vengalakadai Street First Lane Madurai 625001. 27. Dhakshinamoorthy (Exonerated) Proprietor Senthil Traders Business at No. 2 Vengalakadai Street First Lane Madurai 625001. 28. Jeyamani Trading Company Through one of its Partners Jeyamani (Exonerated) Business at No. 3A Vengalakadai Street First Lane Madurai 625001. 29. Sri Anadavar and Co. Through one of its Partners Mahendran (Exonerated) Business at No. 2 Vengalakadai Street First Lane Madurai 625001. 30. S.Sundaresan (Exonerated) Son of S.T. Subramaniapillai Tractor Workshop Door No. 12 PerumalKovil Street Talakulam Madurai 625002. 31. Mariammal (Exonerated) Wife of Mark Business at No. 12 PerumalKovil Street Tallakulam Madurai 625002. 32. S.Siddharthan (Exonerated) Son of SonaiMudaliar DRO Road Opposite Lakshmi Theatre K.Pudur Madurai 625 007. 33. S.Sridharan (Exonerated) Scooter Workshop